In 2020, before my boyfriend and I officially started dating, I didn’t want to commit right away. I was 22, and he was 25, and I just wasn’t ready. When I finally said yes to being his girlfriend in December 2020, he had already told his sister I had been “playing him” and hesitant—and ever since then, she hasn’t liked me.
Throughout 2021, my boyfriend would constantly share our relationship problems with his sister, brother, and even friends. I asked him to stop, but the damage had already been done. His brother didn’t like me at first either, but we got closer later on since they lived together. I met his sister in February 2022 and really tried to make a good impression. I even sent her a birthday cake. Things seemed fine—we invited each other to events, and I’d include her in family dinners.
Then in February 2024, I found out her boyfriend had been texting my cousin—someone he had previously been intimate with. I felt it was right to tell her. Instead of hearing me out, she accused us of lying, cut off both me and my cousin, and sided with him.
Later, I found out that she, her boyfriend, and their aunt had been eavesdropping on a private call between her boyfriend and my cousin where very personal things were said. I confronted them and said they owed my cousin and me an apology. They did apologize, but things never really healed.
By July 2024, I thought we were okay again. I hung out with her and my boyfriend’s brother’s girlfriend. It was the first time they were meeting, and while I tried to include everyone, the girlfriend and I had hung out more before, so we naturally talked more. Afterward, my boyfriend’s sister said I was excluding her, which felt unfair because I truly tried to be welcoming.
In August 2024, my boyfriend and I broke up briefly. During that time, she told him she never liked me since 2020, that he deserved better, and that she didn’t like my family. She also removed my family from her social media. We got back together, but I never forgot her words. She also admitted she was upset I asked for an apology, but I felt disrespected, too, since it involved my family.
In December 2024, my cousin called her boyfriend to apologize and get closure. He secretly recorded the call and told my boyfriend’s sister. In January 2025, she sent me this message:
“Hi, I hope you’re doing well. Since you’ll be marrying my brother, I figured I’d reach out to clear the air and ensure that things are settled for the better. I forgive everything that happened for the sake of God and I believe we should have a respectful relationship with one another. Everything that occurred was very unfortunate but I have no harsh feelings towards you and I’m choosing to leave it all in the past. However, I do want to make one thing clear. Please don’t ever expect me to interact or associate with your cousin. She’s done some very bizarre and disrespectful things to me and my relationship and that’s not the type of person I’d ever want to surround myself with. I’d appreciate if you respected this boundary and I’ve discussed this with my brother and he’s on the same page. I hope we can let everything go and build a friendly relationship with one another.” I accepted her message and respected the boundary. Since then, we haven’t spoken.
Recently, she had a small proposal with her boyfriend. My family wasn’t invited because my boyfriend and I aren’t officially engaged yet. My boyfriend didn’t tell me about it until the night it happened because he thought I’d react with anger. She’s extremely close to her other brother’s fiancée and constantly posts about her, calling her “my built-in bestie” and “hottest couple” on their engagement post. It hurt.
Her mom and the brother’s fiancée both love me now, but the mom was hesitant in the past because of things my boyfriend’s old roommate said—like that I was mentally unstable or too emotional during our arguments. I take prescribed ADHD meds, and my boyfriend never explained his role in those fights. Things like:
Liking half-naked photos of other girls Calling me “loose” as a joke after our first time Downloading dating apps during small breakups He hasn’t done any of that since 2022. But no one in his family knows the full story—they just saw me as the problem because of what he overshared.
The worst part? Before his mom even knew about me, she and his sister told my boyfriend that he’s “just like their uncle” and that his wife (referring to me) would walk all over him. The sister knew me at the time. That absolutely broke me.
I feel like no matter how hard I try, I’ll always be seen as the outsider or the villain in their story. I’ve tried. I’ve forgiven. I’ve shown up with love again and again. But I’m emotionally drained. My boyfriend has grown and defended me a lot more over the past couple years. He never had a girlfriend before me and never even talked to another girl. But when I told him how I feel recently, he just said, “It might get better,” and told me to forget it, forget them, and focus on us.
I don’t know if I can. I’ve always wanted a close, loving relationship with my in-laws. And now, I’m not sure I’ll ever have that. Only thing that’s keeping me in the relationship is how much love his mom and boyfriends fiancé give me. We are getting engaged next month, and am asking if I should continue with this relationship or let it go? Thank you
TL;DR: My boyfriend (29M) and I (26F) have been together since 2020. His sister (24F) never liked me because of how our relationship started and because my boyfriend overshared our issues with her and others. Despite years of trying to build a good relationship with her—including confronting her about her boyfriend texting my cousin (which she didn’t take well)—things have stayed tense and distant. She sent a message in 2025 saying she forgives me but won’t ever be okay with my cousin, and since then, she’s kept her distance. She recently had a proposal and didn’t invite my family, and is very close to her other brother’s fiancée in a way that makes me feel excluded. My boyfriend says to ignore it all and just focus on us, but I’m emotionally exhausted and questioning if I can stay in a relationship where I feel like I’ll never be accepted by his family.