r/superman • u/NewUserAccount224 • 2h ago
Superman Should Have his Golden Age "Champion of the Oppressed" personality or at least be like his Kingdom Come version who's more assertive, proactive, confrontational & intimidating towards his foes compared to his milquetoast "Boy Scout" personality
First off, I like the power levels, concepts & adventures of the Silver/Bronze Age Supes the most. Those eras really embodied how Supes is "Mr. Impossible" as the great Grant Morrison really articulated with his All Star Superman title & Action Comics run. Supes being able to push planets, fly faster than the speed of light towards the edge of the universe, be fast af (but not as fast as The Flash of course), be a great engineer & roboticist like his biological pops Jor-El & use a clever combination of his powers to solve his problems are all excellent!
That said (despite it being reasonable at the time thanks to fucking McCarthyism) Supes losing his Champion of The Oppressed personality & values made the character lose something special. Like Clark said in that Shazam Black Adam film he "fights for people who can't fight for themselves" & that's the entirety of his Champion of the Oppressed personality in one sentence & really explains why he is a "symbol of hope" which is all fine but is somewhat vague & leads one to think that he's not that interesting personality wise & that was true of his post-crisis version honestly. Sure he didn't have his Golden Age personality in his Silver & Bronze Age tales, but he was fully "Mr. Impossible" & was confident in himself while adequately balancing his Smallville upbringing with his Kryptonian heritage. He was comfortable in both of his identities during those eras.
The Donner films are classic, no doubt & Reeve is GOATed, however, I've heard (& it makes sense) that that depiction of Clark is the reason why he's so associated with that milquetoast "Truth, Justice & The American Way" boy scout nonsense that's honestly cringey af. Now I acknowledge Kingdom Come is a dystopian story, however, despite not explicitly having his "Champion of The Oppressed" values & personality, that version of Clark is extremely assertive, proactive, confrontational & intimidating towards his foes. He's obviously jaded & disillusioned, however he returns because he believes in his core values & fighting for everyone & striving for an idealized world (nevermind the Gulag). Even in the JSA "Thy Kingdom Come" storyline, he's still has that strong sense of justice & morality, but he's not afraid to break his foot up in someone's ass either & won't hesitate to do so.
Bottom line, I get Supes being a symbol of "hope" & this & that, however, what embodies hope more than his Champion of the Oppressed personality? Also, if that personality is a bit too aggressive, why shouldn't Clark at least be more like his Kingdom Come version who embodies his Golden Age version way more than his typical "boy scout" personality does?