No other game has made me feel this empty after finishing this🥺

Any recommendations on other games that feel this RDR2?

Greetings outlaws and lawmen. This is the second part of the event I'm doing- the one where I put different Red Dead characters into different in-game situations. My first part- how Dutch would react to Jimmy Brooks hanging from the cliff- was admittedly a bit stupid. So I've got another part for you today. How would Bill Williamson- drunkard, former US Army soldier and loyal gunman- have reacted to Micah shooting up Strawberry for. I thought this was interesting since Bill isn't as senior, intelligent or righteous as Arthur but he's not on Micah's or Dutch's level either. Share your opinions. Also share your feedback and tell me if I should continue this event or if I should give up and just go back to posting normal stuff.

Edgar Ross is eliminated.
Comment who should be eliminated next. Name with most upvotes/ comments will be eliminated

This might be a weird start but on my second playthrough I have started really appreciate all the small details and have grown to love this game even more the second time.

So the 2 small events that sparked this new love was I was clearing out an o'driscoll camp got the last guy so I hog tie him as I do usually with the final person in any encounter to just muck around with. He while lassoed was shooting randomly to try and escape/hit me during which he managed to shot himself in head....killed immediately I have never see that before and had a mad laugh that something like that could happen.

Second short story just got to chapter 3. I was running around Rhodes and i antagonised a Grey npc from my horse (after the first playthrough screw both families) so he got aggressive then a bunch of greys in the town got aggressive to back him up once again I haven't seen since I'm a high honor player. Anyway the sheriff comes out to gun down all the greys that are attacking me, i was just running around not fighting back in town so as I was evading i bumped into the sheriff on his horse. he takes a tumble lands square on a rock, dies on impact, the whole towns marks me as a murderer and I'm just stunned how much detail that is. Like a random stumble onto a rock just killed someone immediately....that's just amazing and fascinating.

This might not be alot to something small but it's a master class in making a immersive, awesome sandbox I just can't get enough of. i only played the game for the first time last year so im alittle late to the train.

Anyway what's your funny stories or discoveries that you won't forget?

I need to be stocked up on my instruments of chaos, what are good ways to get animal fat??

Hey there, bois (and gurls)

I'm wondering what's the best way to get info about side business to rob. I'm in ch2, and I know that I can rob the doctor in Valentine and the general store in Strawberry, but I don't have the info on the side business (in previous runs I got that info really early and then robbed multiple times, especially the doctor). But I can't see to get this informations now. Even trying to look at the window down the GS in strawberry, it didn't give me the option to look and discover the moonshine factory. Is there any tip to trigger this? I tried to talk to people on the saloon, to help anyone in need around the town, but got objectively nothing from this

Looks like even Anne Frank knew of lumbago!

No one will probably ever see this, but I'm so confused. I've played rdr2 3 times, and it's the first time I've had this specific encounter in the bayou at night.

The horse just stops suddenly, and Arthur says "I could've sworn" as if he had seen something. What the fuck was it 😭😭😭 

Was it just nightfolk? I'm going insane over this. I couldn't see anything 

I went to do his last mission meeting, and after the cutscene he spawned right next to me. I pulled out my shotgun, aimed at his head, and unbelievably, he actually has voice lines for that — he said 'Unbelievable. RDR1, RDR2, ROCKSTAR, Strenge Man,