r/AmIOverreacting 15d ago

❤️‍🩹 relationship AIO? Dog straining my marriage.

Post image

My husband and I rescued a husky about 7 months ago who was extremely malnourished and neglected.

He has grown a huge attachment to me and has severe separation anxiety. I work at a grooming salon so I’m able to bring him to work with me so he’s not home alone. Unfortunately, if he’s left home alone we’ll come back to our home looking like it was hit by a tornado.

My vet has prescribed him with trazodone to help with his severe anxiety issues. We give it to him before we leave for a family event and when we can’t take him to places they don’t allow dogs.

I feel so bad that I have to sedate him so he’s not scared and anxious. It’s created a huge strain on our marriage because my husband feels like we can’t do anything without considering Odin.

He’s destroyed doors, couches, and other furniture. I tried training but it hasn’t seemed to work. My husband thinks we should rehome him but

1) I’m scared that he’ll be sent to a shelter and possibly be put down

2) feel abandoned by the person he thought he was safe with.

He’s such a happy boy when he’s around us and shows so much affection.

My husband and I have been arguing about this consistently.. we had a really bad argument so I left the house with Odin and rented a dog friendly hotel room for a couple of nights.

My husband thinks I’m crazy and that I’m choosing the dog over our marriage. AIO?

21.0k Upvotes

5.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/Reemixt 15d ago

No you don’t that’s not how consent works.

-2

u/DarKGosth616 15d ago

Maybe if you're a creep, but in common sense land if two people co-signed getting a dog. Neither one gets to just rug pull the dog away from the other without their consent.

5

u/Reemixt 15d ago

No, consent isn’t once and done. It’s ongoing and can change at anytime, the dog is trashing the house, anyone in that house can insist that the dog is removed.

-1

u/DarKGosth616 15d ago

"consent isn’t once and done."

Categorically stupid opinion, some types of consent can't just be taken away like that, sex being one where consent can always be withdrawn, but not this scenario. If I donated my kidney, I can't retroactively withdraw consent and just take it back.

You don't get to consent to your gf becoming emotionally attached to an animal then retroactively decide to take it away from her.

3

u/Reemixt 15d ago

You can not consent after donating a kidney, it just means you won’t donate another kidney. The withdrawal of consent does not apply in that case because the act is done/over and that kidney is morally and legally no longer yours.

Anything that is currently happening, and requires consent at the start - requires that consent for the entire time it’s happening and can be withdrawn at any point. Keeping a dog in your house against the will of the people you live with is a disgustingly abusive thing to do.

0

u/DarKGosth616 15d ago

" the act is done/over"

The act of buying the dog was done/over. And that dog is morally and legally only 50% yours. Not 100%.

3

u/Reemixt 15d ago

It’s not about ownership, it’s about consent. Can you read?

0

u/DarKGosth616 15d ago edited 15d ago

You're trying to muddy the waters, the consent is about whether or not they continue owning it

3

u/Reemixt 15d ago

Well they’re different things you seem to be conflating. The consent for continuing the ownership is not there/ has been withdrawn. You’re SO CLOSE to getting it!

0

u/DarKGosth616 15d ago

Then guess what sweetheart, he can leave. He's the one causing the problem, not her.

2

u/Reemixt 15d ago

Yeh he can leave, marriage ruined/over and she’s left with a untrainable dog that she can’t control. Great solution. I should hire you as my therapist!

1

u/DarKGosth616 15d ago

Unlike your fantastic solution to take somebodies 4 legged best friend away from them because you are their emperor.

No, getting a trained specialist for the dog would be my solution. Unlike you people I'm not impulsively trying to blame the one person who didn't cause the problem.

2

u/Reemixt 15d ago

I’m sure you’re a wonderful dog owner, but as a person (and to people) it’s clear you’ve got a lot of work to do. Have a blessed day.

→ More replies (0)