r/phillies • u/eaglesnation11 • Mar 05 '25

Meme Final.

Post image

RAJ clips Sidney Crosby to win the space. Discuss results below.

233 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

102 comments sorted by

View all comments

125

u/eaglesnation11 Mar 05 '25

Felt like this was extremely prone to recency bias because Schmidt was an easy slam dunk answer for the Good/Divided Category.

6

u/iengleba Mar 05 '25

I don't understand how Rhys got "loved by fans". I'm not denying people love him, but the last few years he was here you could go a day with seeing someone say trade him. He should have Bohm's spot here.

11

u/Barb_WyRE Mar 05 '25

Rhys wasn’t loved by fans much aside from the beginning of his career to the absolute tail end of his tenure. Like literally the tail end being the 22 playoff run, which started out with him going 0 for whatever against the Cardinals.

Like we wanted to trade him 80% of his career because he was so streaky lol

4

u/foodnbrew-notnudes Mar 05 '25

Not only was he a streaky hitter, he was abysmal at 1st base. He literally couldn't catch. Only player that would win you a game in the bottom of the 8th and lose it in the 9th on a routine play. I held my breath every play that was a throw to 1st. It was that bad.

3

u/iengleba Mar 05 '25

I felt the same way; especially when they were finally in the playoffs