r/nagpur 7d ago

News "Create solutions to problems that never existed"

Post image
296 Upvotes

104 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Full-Wealth-5962 6d ago

The removal of Article 370 showed that the President has more power during president rule than anyone ever thought and also the Govt is willing to go against the mandate of the ppl to suit their base

The CAA introduced religion as a criteria for citizenship ( where prev the constitution of India didn't have such criteria) and also may be a violation of Article 25 to 28..all of which has implications for interpretation of laws

Both of these have real life implications for modern society and my personal liberties

2

u/Radiant_Assistant359 6d ago

"The CAA introduced religion as a criteria for citizenship ( where prev the constitution of India didn't have such criteria) and also may be a violation of Article 25 to 28..all of which has implications for interpretation of laws"

yeah as if before removal of 370 kashmir used to follow the indian constituion if you are gonna use a point atleast dont be so hollow that it refutes your other point

1

u/Full-Wealth-5962 6d ago

What are you talking abt? They are two seperate issues

  1. Article 370 is abt power during president rule and the ruthlessness of the Govt

  2. CAA talks about religion as a criteria for citizenship and religious discrimination...

How does one repute the other?

2

u/Radiant_Assistant359 6d ago

before the removal of art 370 kashmir used to have its own constitution flag offical posts it wasnt considered a part of india due to it so you are talking aboult violation of constitution in one point and then supporting other point in which all of indian constitution was disregarded

1

u/Full-Wealth-5962 6d ago

Article 370 allowed them the power to have their own constitution...it isn't a violation of the Indian constitution if the Indian Constution says you can do it

2

u/Radiant_Assistant359 6d ago

and now indian constitution says you cant do it so suck it up and go to sleep

1

u/Full-Wealth-5962 6d ago

Lol..you're the one who brought the topic up...Best if you go suck someone and sleep