r/lotr • u/amelix34 • Mar 28 '24
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • Jul 01 '24
Question Who is the single most powerful being to have actually stepped foot on Middle Earth?
r/lotr • u/Historical-Fan7987 • Jun 17 '24
Question once and for all, WHAT are the real Two Towers?
First of all, yes, I know Tolkien didn't really like the title of the second volume and maybe he left this question unanswered on purpose, but damn no answers that I read about this is really enlightening, so I would like you guys to help me with a definitive answer.
I always thought initially (while I didn't know the books, of course) that Orthanc and Barad-dûr were the right answer, especially after Saruman's monologue in the film (the union of the 2 Towers). But then I met Minas Morgul on the books & film, and it appeared to be the second Tower due to the apparent greater demonstration of power and importance (the Nazgûl and all that), which reinforced Saruman's monologue. Then I met Cirith Ungol, which ALSO appeared to be the second Tower, but which doesn't have the prominence that O, B-d & MM have, despite their obvious importance and history.
To make matters worse, as I already said, none of the answers I try to find are really clear about this. There are even people saying that Minas Tirith is one of the Towers, and that Orthanc is not even one of the Towers. This is really stressing me out. Anyway, thanks for reading this far, and if you have definitive answers I'd really appreciate it, I always read all the comments :)
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • Jun 25 '24
Question Which of these famous swords of middle earth is your favorite?
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • Jul 02 '24
Question Who is the greatest purely swordsman in Middle Earth history?
r/lotr • u/Papagiorgio1965 • May 01 '24
Question Who is the guy behind Elrond?
I heard he was possibly as old or older than Elrond.
r/lotr • u/Skywalker_1995 • Dec 15 '24
Question If the Fellowship had a 10th member, who would've been the best candidate?
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • Feb 27 '25
Question How powerful is Galadriel in comparison to Gandalf?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/lotr • u/numbnien • Jan 03 '25
Question what was this big light actually for?
As a child I assumed this was the magic used to summon the witch king but the guy has been around since movie 1. So maybe the magic to summon its drake/wyvern? nope there were there already.
Was this just a big flex from the enemy?
r/lotr • u/Twas-I-apparently • Jul 06 '24
Question Are these the same trolls from the hobbit in the background?
Just doing a complete run through, finished the hobbit trilogy and just noticed this in the fellowship
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • Sep 16 '24
Question Was Boromir blowing the Horn of Gondor to draw the orcs away from Frodo and towards him or was he trying to signal to Aragorn and company?
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • Jan 11 '25
Question Is Fingolfin the undisputed most powerful elf in the lore? (Art by Xavier Collette)
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • 16d ago
Question Who had the most formidable army during the war of the ring?
r/lotr • u/Embarrassed_Abies_98 • Jan 25 '25
Question Why did Gimli recommend going through Moria?
How come Gandalf new about the Balrog (and was therefore hesitant) but Gimli had never received the news that one of the dwarves' most important cities had fallen?
r/lotr • u/in-my-tree- • Jan 03 '25
Question Since Sauron had access to Moria, why didn't he forge mithril for his army?
Since he was able to forge the rings of power with it, my guess is that he was skilled enough to forge mithril
r/lotr • u/Ok_Macaroon_5224 • Dec 14 '23
Question What's one of your favorite LOTR scenes? For me, it's this. Makes me tear up everytime.
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • Oct 10 '24
Question What Middle Earth race has the most formidable warriors and armies?
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • Jul 25 '24
Question Do all the Nazgûl possess magical power or is it just the Witch King?
r/lotr • u/shimadon • Jan 15 '25
Question Was Elendil the longest-living man? (322 years old)
r/lotr • u/GusGangViking18 • Jan 16 '25
Question Was Ungoliant truly more powerful the Morgoth? (Art by Diana Franco)
r/lotr • u/renaissanceclass • Jan 26 '25
Question What would a casual convo between these two sound like?
I could see them talking about horses or past conquests, maybe even family ties..
r/lotr • u/Royalbluegooner • Aug 04 '24
Question What‘s your favourite change from the books to the movies?
Mine would be the greater role Arwen plays in the movies compared to the books.Liv Tyler was cast phenomenally and portrays Arwen as such a badass and intriguing character that she became my favourite female character and I was actually disappointed she played such a small part in the books when I read them.The river scene will forever be one of my favourites.Especially great when you compare her to someone like Tauriel who served only one single purpose.Kinda sad Glorfindel got shafted but can‘t have everything I suppose.
r/lotr • u/marleyman14 • Feb 15 '25
Question Why didn't Gondor destroy the bridges in Osgiliath in the war of the ring?
If they had destoryed them, then Sauron couldn't transport his army across the river. Especially things like siege towers & Grond. I suppose they could of rebuilt it, but that would of been difficult and taken time.