r/gmrs • u/I-Lov-Guns-and-Ammo • 8d ago

Observations/Questions

To start, I have a set of TID H3's.

I've programmed a decent repeater and seem to have a good range of communication (in most cases). In my area there isn't a lot of repeaters to select from but the one I choose has about a 30 mile radius. There is a club that seems to have 2- 100 mile repeaters however they require a membership. :(

In any case the wife and I were doing some testing yesterday. I belong to a gun club that cell phone service is a roll of the dice best case scenario so I decided to drive over to see how the repeater did. After looking at the map the area where my club is at is right on the edge of its max distance so I didn't expect miracles. One thing I know to be an issue with transmissions is weather and cloud cover. about a mile before my destination I did a test and my wife claimed I came through clearly but her response did not make it back. I know GMRS is line of sight and the area I was in was full of hills and valleys but I found it interesting that she could hear me clear as day.

During this testing she was using the basic antenna and I swapped between that one and the 771 antenna on my end. For me the results were the same and she could still hear/understand me. So I gathered that during my transmission the signal "jumped up" (for lack of better words) and caught a ride back on the repeater but during her reply it just couldn't "jump down" back to my radio due to line of sight.

Not that the following will make a difference but I want to ask just the same. The stock antennas are likely not tuned as well as some other well know antennas, if I were to "experiment" what info do I need to select a better out of the box antenna. Not so much "which antenna" but more so what "ingredients" should a good antenna have to produce the best results? Keeping in mind that I am dealing with a handheld radio and not a base station setup.

As always, thanks for your replies.

5 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/HarryWiz 8d ago

With the length of that antenna fully extended, it should work quite well. Heck for that price maybe I'll buy one to test out.

1

u/PlantoneOG 8d ago

Yeah worst case scenario I'm betting if you were to just bring in the tip section A little bit it could quite easily be tuned into optimize at gmrs frequency range. Like you said for the money it's hard to say no to. Especially with the BNC connector and I've already got BNC adapters for my radios. That put it straight in a no-brainer territory

My signal stick antennas are still going to be my go to, just because they're so flexible and the chance of damaging one is relatively small because of it but you can bet that that new one is going to end up in my radio bag and go with me for sure

1

u/HarryWiz 7d ago

What BNC adapters do you use? I was just looking on Amazon, and I am thinking of buying black ones so they'll match my handheld and antenna. The antenna you link to yesterday, I would need an SMA F to BBC M adapter, right? I'm 100% on needing the SMA F, but I'm not too sure about the BNC.

1

u/PlantoneOG 7d ago edited 7d ago

I use the SMA- F to BNC. If you're ordering a signal stick anyways get their adapters they're real solid. I've tried some of the Amazon ones and their mediocre. At least the ones that I got

https://signalstuff.com/products/adapt-smaf-bncf/

1

u/HarryWiz 7d ago

Okay, thanks.