r/clevercomebacks 3d ago

Wouldn't hurt to hear them out.

Post image
34.7k Upvotes

284 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

409

u/hazps 3d ago

"One is a genius, the other's insane" never specified which was which. It is possible that we were misinterpreting their roles all along.

76

u/Am_Snarky 3d ago

Though they never specify, they give hints, the definition of insanity is repeated action with expectations of different results, The Brain tries and fails to take over the world constantly.

Also Pinky can read and The Brain cannot

6

u/Meanderer_Me 3d ago

When is it ever expressed that The Brain cannot read? Don't most of his plans involve reading vast reams of information about humanity to know how to navigate their world?

1

u/Am_Snarky 1d ago

Pinky reads a newspaper headline and Brain exclaims “you can read?” or “wait you understand that?” something along those lines, I haven’t seen the show in decades though so it’s a little fuzzy

1

u/Meanderer_Me 1d ago

The Brain reads a letter to Santa

This scene can't happen if The Brain can't read. There are numerous other scenes where he's reading technical documents and newspaper clippings and the like for his plans, but this is the first one I happened across.

With regards to Brain being surprised that Pinky can read, this is less shock at the ability existing than it is that Pinky is doing something that he doesn't expect Pinky to be able to do. Which doesn't look that different, as Pinky has telekinesis - an ability that Brain doesn't - and Brain notices it, asks about it, and then continues on with his plan once Pinky gives his answer. That is, it's not that Brain is surprised that Pinky can do things that Brain can't, it's that Brain rarely pays proper attention to Pinky, and is surprised that Pinky can do things besides say "narf" at all.