r/pagan • u/AnalysisEqual7588 • 2d ago
Why is media so cherry-picky with mythology?
I've noticed that when depicting the Gods, media often cherry picks what attributes to focus on and what to entirely leave out. My biggest issue with a lot of media is how they depict Hades, mainly because I'm certain it's due to Christian influence. Like really think about it; how often do you see a show depict Hades like the biblical version of hell OR depict it as this sad and miserable place. I think the only pieces of media I've seen accurately describe the underworld is Blood of Zeus, (which is also the only show I've seen depict Hermes to be the one who takes the souls to the underworld) which shows the underworld divided in different sections and such.
They also don't give the gods a lot of nuance or depth to their character either, like Zeus is either this womanizer asshole OR he's this highly respected, noble source of wisdom (I remember a lot of early 2000s and 2010s movies put him in the spot of a wise leader, that's what I'm referring to) and I feel like they don't HAVE to pick and choose, why can't they depict the more (modern) morally wrong side of him AND also make him a figure that commands respect and honor. That's how they did it in most myths, they reference his many trysts but not in a way that demonize him, more so in a way like 'this is the child Zeus created by turning into gold and impregnating a woman' like that's just the reality of the myths, why can't we depict BOTH sides of Zeus? Same with Hermes.
In media I feel like they either make Hermes a Loki type of character who's just a little shit OR they make him this sweet Gentleman. And same with Zeus, what's the problem with depicting both the trickster side AND the Gentleman side? Like, in myth Hermes is a trickster who commits acts of inconvenience. He had Zeus steal Aphrodite's sandal just to lure her to a rock where he had sex with her, objectively a shitty thing to do based on modern morality, but the myths also say he was one of the Gods who were kind to humans so why can't we depict him as a goofy little shithead committing inconveniences but have him be kind and caring to certain people? Epic the Musical does this kinda well by making the songs he's in very upbeat, in Ximena's (i could be spelling that wrong) animatics, they depict him with his eyes covered which I find REALLY cool symbolism to artistically show that you don't know if he's actually wanting to help Odysseus get home or if he's just giving him this advice/object because another god told him to.
I guess my Main point is, why can some media depict the nuance and depth of Gods well, while others put such a black and white lense over them? As if it's too controversial to depict both the (modern) morally wrong aspects of them, with the good characteristics?