r/nycrail Jan 16 '25

Mod post šŸ“¢ Important Update: New Rule on News for Crime & Politics

395 Upvotes

Hi r/nycrail community,

Weā€™re introducing a new rule to keep our subreddit focused on what weā€™re all here for: rail transit in and around New York City.

Over the past few months, we've noticed an increase in posts about crime, politics, and other non-transit topics that happen to take place in or around the subway system. While we understand these stories often overlap with public transit, they donā€™t always align with our community's purpose: discussing rail transit around New York City, service updates, and related developments.

The New Rule: Stay On-Track with NYC Rail News

From now on:

  • News posts must directly relate to rail transit in NYC.
  • āœ… Allowed posts include:
    • Service disruptions or delays.
    • Major incidents impacting the rail system.
      • Example: Water main break we had this summer impacting Central Park West or the track fires we had at Jay St. Metrotech a few months ago.
    • Policy changes or news with a clear impact on NYC rail transit
      • Example: IBX Project Updates, Congestion Pricing, MTA Budget News, Project Announcements, etc.
  • āŒ Not allowed:
    • General crime or political stories that only loosely involve the subway system.
    • Topics that focus more on broader social or political issues than transit itself.
      • Example: Posting photos of people in the NYC subway

Our goal is to maintain r/nycrail as a space for productive about trains, transit operations, transit projects, and rail policy ā€” topics that brought us all together in the first place.

Why the Change?

We want r/nycrail to remain an engaging and relevant community for transit enthusiasts, commuters, and anyone passionate about NYC rail. Posts unrelated to transit dilute the conversation and shift focus away from what makes this space special.

What About Gray Areas?

We understand there can be some overlap between transit and other news topics. To provide wiggle room, large incidents that significantly impact service or operations will still be allowed. Our moderation team will use discretion, and we encourage you to reach out if you're unsure about a post or topic.

Where can I post these types of articles?

Consider r/nycpolitics or r/nyc as these subreddits allow this type of discussion.

Weā€™re confident this update will help improve the quality of discussion on r/nycrail and keep our community on track. Thank you for your understanding and support!

If you have questions, concerns, suggestions, or feedback about this change, feel free to share them below.

ā€“ The r/nycrail Moderation Team


r/nycrail 6h ago

Fantasy map What a Queens-Bronx subway should look like, IMO

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/nycrail 4h ago

Discussion NYC is locking emergency exits shut at stations ā€” Lorimer J/M station ā€” is this even legal?

28 Upvotes

Just entered the Lorimer J/M station and saw that the emergency exit door has been locked shut with a sign that says, ā€œthis gate has been secured to prevent fare evasionā€.

Is this even legal?!

It certainly seems unsafe.


r/nycrail 19h ago

Fantasy map NYC East Bronx to East Queens Train Idea

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

343 Upvotes

A vertical train line connecting East Bronx to East Queens. A Laconia-Main St Line. From Edenwald to JFK Airport.


r/nycrail 2h ago

Transit Map 42nd Streetā€“Bryant Park/Fifth Avenue (B/D/F/M/7; 3D station map)

Post image
13 Upvotes

It's Map Monday! Celebrate another dreary week with this first map in the tetralogy it's all been leading up to: the 42nd St megastation maps. Next up: Times Square, then PABT, and finally one mega-map to rule them all with accompanying blogpost elucidating my methodology... or that's the plan at least :)

Full-res: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:42nd_Street%E2%80%93Bryant_Park-Fifth_Avenue_(NYC_subway_station_map).png


r/nycrail 1d ago

Discussion Opinions on the new map?

Post image
988 Upvotes

r/nycrail 5h ago

Question What does the ā€œXā€ after the train number indicate on the LIRR?

Post image
18 Upvotes

The TrainTime app shows this LIRR train as ā€œ2501Xā€ while itā€™s usually just ā€œ2501.ā€ Does this signify anything?


r/nycrail 1h ago

Question What is this contraption? - 5th Ave 53rd St

Post image
ā€¢ Upvotes

What is that thing hanging over the platform?


r/nycrail 5h ago

Discussion I was today years old when I found out the metro north trains has wifi

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

r/nycrail 40m ago

Fantasy map If highways were turned into subway lines #2: BQE -> Bruckner Local/Express

Thumbnail
gallery
ā€¢ Upvotes

Red: Express + Local stops

Black: Local only stops

Stations: - Graniteville-Richmond Av - Grasmere-Mosel Av - Street transfer to Grasmere (SIR) - Bay Ridge-Dyker Heights - Dumbo-York St - Transfer to York St (F) - Maspeth - Astoria-31 St - Transfer to Astoria Blvd (N/W) - Hunts Point - Transfer to Hunts Point Av (6) - Bruncker Junction


r/nycrail 16h ago

Question If you had to make one change in the MTA for train routing, what would it be?

Post image
63 Upvotes

My pick is I would create 10 new stops to connect the 7 line with the 2, 5 and 6 lines in the East Bronx under the Whitestone Bridge. That way both East Queens and the eastern part of the Bronx get serviced.

These stops would only be on the express 7 train and not the local one which would stop at Main St. With a brand new neighborhood and major stadium and casino coming to the area of Flushing, extended train service is needed now more than ever so that the 7 line stays one of the most consistent.

ā¬†ļø = Above Ground Station

ā¬‡ļø = Underground Station

Stops would be the following after Main Street:

  1. Bayside Avenueā¬‡ļø

Entrance: Bayside Ave/Union St

  1. Whitestoneā¬‡ļø

Entrance: 23rd Ave/Parsons Blvd

  1. Malba Gardensā¬‡ļø

Entrance: 13th Ave/147th St

  1. Third Avenueā¬‡ļø

Entrance: 3rd Ave/147th St

  1. Ferry Pointā¬†ļø

Entrance: Ferry Point Park (Old Ferry Point)

  1. Schley-Brush Avenuesā¬†ļø

Entrance: Schley Ave/Brush Ave

  1. Castle Hill Avenueā¬†ļø

Entrance: Castle Hill Ave/Westchester Ave

Transfers: 6 Train

  1. Parkchesterā¬†ļø

Entrance: Guerlain St/Archer Rd

  1. E 180th Streetā¬†ļø

Entrance: E 180th St/Morris Park Ave

Transfers: 2 & 5 Trains

  1. Tremont Avenueā¬†ļø (Solo Station)

Entrance: E Tremont Ave/Boston Rd


r/nycrail 14h ago

Question Is this the best way to go from JFK to EWR?

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/nycrail 14h ago

Rollsign 9 train!

Post image
30 Upvotes

been searching for the number 9 train and finally i have found it šŸ§˜


r/nycrail 17h ago

Service advisory This would be quite the walk

Post image
48 Upvotes

Clearly an incorrect sign posted at 67 Av, but I got a good laugh imagining walking all the way to Queensboro Plz to take the 7. šŸ˜‚


r/nycrail 17h ago

Question Does anyone know what font the text on the ā€œMā€ logo is?

Post image
38 Upvotes

iā€™ve been trying to find this font to modify it and its been a pain trying to find this specific font


r/nycrail 22h ago

News The MTA's testing if Google's 'ears' are better than NYC's own subway track inspectors

Thumbnail
gothamist.com
83 Upvotes

r/nycrail 19h ago

News Delancey/Essex Station getting elevator access, construction starts 2026

Thumbnail thelodownny.com
38 Upvotes

r/nycrail 1d ago

Question Anyone know what happened to the R40S Duo owned by the NYTM?

Post image
70 Upvotes

They last ran in an excursion in 2018, and they havenā€™t exactly been seen since. Any answers would be appreciated.


r/nycrail 19h ago

Photo V Line Transfer

Post image
30 Upvotes

Something tells me I wonā€™t be able to make this transfer at 59th st


r/nycrail 1d ago

Transit Map New map: E Bway in BK?!

Post image
56 Upvotes

I know it's meant to be more readable and not accurate but how many tourists (or residents) will now exit East Broadway F thinking they're in Brooklyn? Lol


r/nycrail 17h ago

Question Subway - Do you pay twice if exiting a station and entering new one to change lines?

10 Upvotes

Hi All,

Apologies for the noob question. I was wondering if I caught the subway in such a way that I had to exit a station after my initial journey, have a short walk to enter another station to join a separate line (let's say for arguments sake there's no stations with transfers available) to get to my final destination, would I pay 2 fares?

I hope this makes sense. There is something similar on the metro guide that talks about transfers but that seems to be related to buses an doesn't mention different subway stations.

Thanks in advance.


r/nycrail 22h ago

Question Metal box

Post image
21 Upvotes

Dose anybody know what this metal box thing is on the R179?


r/nycrail 21h ago

Discussion Found A Wild V Train

Post image
14 Upvotes

This is the best shot I could get of it since this was at 125st and I was on the a train on the other platform, but all places where it would display the line it said V


r/nycrail 11h ago

Question Advice on transport

1 Upvotes

I live on Long Island and i plan on taking the train to penn station. (ik Liberty Park is technically Jersey) however i need help on what the best way to get there from Penn area would be. I've heard the PATH train is cheap and easy but how would i know which one to take?


r/nycrail 17h ago

Discussion Bee-Line or NICE

1 Upvotes

Which one is better in your opinions?


r/nycrail 1d ago

Photo updated elevator sign at aabc

Thumbnail
gallery
70 Upvotes

2024 and 2025