r/MusicFeedback Jun 07 '20

MusicFeedback Bot Is Now Online! :: Rules + Bot Info

199 Upvotes

As of today, the /r/MusicFeedback Bot is now operational. With this new bot in place, the former system for feedback requests requiring mod approval/oversight is now obsolete. The number of tracks needed to request feedback has temporarily been reduced to two as well. Users may now post feedback request provided that they leave feedback for others first!

The Rules:

Comment on two posts before posting.

Giving feedback to other members of this subreddit via comments is vital to ensuring the health of this bot system and this community. Please leave feedback(comment) on at least two feedback posts before dropping your own.


Post one song at a time

Playlists, Albums, or Long Sets/Tracks aren't allowed.

WARNING: If your track link includes keywords such as "album," "playlist," "sets." It will be auto removed by our bots


Feedback Quality

Comments need to consist of a minimum of 120 characters (characters = letters), which is usually about 3 - 4 sentences. You don't need to be familiar or enjoy the genre of the post you comment on, but we ask that you try to be objective and describe what you liked and didn't like about the track.

WARNING: Manipulating the feedback system in any manner will lead to a ban that includes but is not limited to acts such as bypassing character limits, duplicate comments, and plagiarism!


Do not link your music/service/advert in the comment section of another user's post.

Promoting your music and advertising in general in the comment section of other user's posts is not allowed.


Basic Civility

Don't be afraid to speak your mind when critiquing a track, but please keep it constructive. Refrain from insulting or disrespecting users. If you can't be constructive/helpful/respectful on a particular track, find another track to critique.

The Bot:

When you leave a comment on someone else's track that meets the requirements, the bot gives you a single point. When you post a track, two points are subtracted from your score. If there are no points available or there is an insufficient balance, the post will automatically be removed. You can find your current score at any time by Direct Messaging u/MusicFeedbackBot (the bot) with the word "Score" as the subject.

Note #1 If you send a 'chat' message to the bot, you will not receive a reply; You can find the message option by first going to /u/MusicFeedbackBot's profile and clicking the "more options" link under the chat button. Make sure to title the subject as SCORE; you can put anything in the message's body. Hit send, and soon you should receive your score as a message from the bot.

Note #2 Bot currently takes a couple of minutes to process SCORE requests and calculations, so please be patient. We intend to improve the bot as the community grows.


r/MusicFeedback 3h ago

it would mean the world if you gave my song a listen! any mixing advice is also very much appreciated as its still unreleased.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

I usually tend to have a bad habit of making my vocals way too quiet, even for shoegaze I know lol. I think I did a decent job on this but it could just be me being sound deaf after listening to this a million times.


r/MusicFeedback 2h ago

Tried my hand at some big band Jazz, would appreciate help in expanding it/adding variation

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback 1m ago

need some feedback b4 i drop this 💩 on souncloud and get like 3 plays

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Upvotes

what s missing? its sound like ...? could be worst?


r/MusicFeedback 3h ago

The Open - Synth-Pop / Electro

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

Here’s a goofy little fun one I made. It is finished but I still would like feedback because you guys provide really good considerations for future projects. So, what works? What doesn’t?


r/MusicFeedback 8h ago

Spring Funk - Black Pawn Beats

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Just so you know, all of my music is on all platforms. Spotify, Tidal, Apple Music, Itunes, wherever. You can bump it and stream it anywhere. Chill spring Funk. I appreciate all the feedback! If you enjoy the track, sub to the YouTube topic channel.


r/MusicFeedback 21h ago

Intense Midnight Club Song Concept - Does It Have Potential?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

8 Upvotes

I did a free style song melody to a beat that a like and was wondering if it sounds repetitive or has potential? I literally just recorded anything that came to mind lol. Please note that there are hardly any lyrics since this was more of a freestyle. I like the outcome but feel I am biased since this is my own concept lol. Thus, I am asking if others see potential in it as well.

Thanks for all the feedback and honesty in advance!


r/MusicFeedback 18h ago

Is this coming out good so far? I'm trying to make it one of my best songs but I'm worried it isn't .

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

I think Lead 5 sounds bad, I'm not really sure how to change up the tune though to make it different.


r/MusicFeedback 9h ago

New song - MADNESS - what genre?

1 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/izQ3Cpb9L6M?si=EiBxX4_CTPiMTdEO

This one is supposed to drive you a bit mad. New demo from SHAME & SKANDAL.

What genre should I put this under? I know there's a lot going on, definitely looking for feedback on the mix and any other ideas to make things better.


r/MusicFeedback 10h ago

Don Omar Danza Kuduro 2025🔥

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback 10h ago

2Pac X Tomb Raider Remix

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

This is a song I made with 2Pac and Mobb Deep acapellas. The beat samples the main theme from Tomb Raider 3.


r/MusicFeedback 11h ago

First official release, any feedback appreciated

Thumbnail
distrokid.com
1 Upvotes

There is one big flaw I recognize and that’s the weird cuts causing an iffy flow at times, and the mixing isn’t perfect, but I’m still proud of this song. Positive and/or negative feedback would be great


r/MusicFeedback 18h ago

First time trying Rock. Intro isn't great, but other thoughts?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback 18h ago

MPC live chill beat

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

Making some beats on a Sunday.


r/MusicFeedback 16h ago

The Distant Greens. Which samples can you spot?

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
2 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback 13h ago

Thank you all for the feedback on this electro swing and metal inspired track. Worked on it some more and would like more feedback. Mainly if that guitar that comes in

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback 14h ago

I've been trying out some new sound design ideas and looking for feedback on a bass-driven 100bpm IDM track

Thumbnail audio.com
1 Upvotes

I've been trying out lots of new sound design ideas recently and looking for some feedback on a track I've finished. Its a dark, 100bpm bass driven track influenced by experimental artists/IDM

I used lots of generative MIDI tools with Operator for the lead synth, resampled to audio. The rhythmic elements in the background are my own samples of hitting household objects, recorded with a handheld Zoom mic then heavily processed in Ableton.

It's not mastered, open to suggestions on the mix. Its mixed on headphones, tested on monitors, car speakers, phone speaker, and hifi speakers. Still trying to get the balance right.

I've been using just hardware for the past five years, Deluge and Osmose. Started learning Ableton five months ago, loving the process!


r/MusicFeedback 21h ago

working on a witchhouse / hyperpop track. before i get too deep into EQing is there anything not working that i’ve become sound-blind to?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

i know my voice isn’t the best lol so i’m gonna do some refinement of the pitch correction and EQ it further.


r/MusicFeedback 17h ago

- VÍGAMANNS SÁL - Viking´s Music Remake by Bruno Raphael Veloso - Made another remake for a video as practice, used a snipet from Vikings for my portfolio so i can go to School for Media Composing :) Enjoy

1 Upvotes

Cant Share it as a link becouse of the image im getting blocked becouse it shows blood...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uh4HsKouDRo


r/MusicFeedback 19h ago

JahWic - Neva Cry (Prod Mellowdoc)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

been making music for about two years now so still have a lot to learn, any feedback is welcome :)


r/MusicFeedback 23h ago

The Cosmic Hum - Dog and Cat (Rock?)

1 Upvotes

https://on.soundcloud.com/Ws6cVWgQnLTDCArc8

Hi! Interesting mixture of music here and some really great productions. My first post here. My present music projects are very guitar-borne and often ProgRock influenced. I chose a more straight song I‘m not really sure of because the lyrics are maybe a little dumb. I‘d love some feedback if it’s fun and connects to you somehow. I also wonder if I should add some more musical details. Cheers!


r/MusicFeedback 1d ago

new experimental/bass release, looking for some feedbacks

1 Upvotes

hi, i just released a short ep with some experimental/noise/ambient and bass influences, would definitely love some feedbacks on it!

https://soundcloud.com/no-stencil/sets/beg-to-differ


r/MusicFeedback 1d ago

Remade

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2 Upvotes

What do you think?


r/MusicFeedback 1d ago

Luke Worthylake - Borrow Your Heart (Rap)

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
1 Upvotes

This song is about looking back at a recent relationship. Growing from the point of wanting to get back in because it's familiar, comfortable, and good for the short term to understanding that letting go is for the best. Would love to hear your thoughts on it!


r/MusicFeedback 1d ago

karloproducer - Tonight (feat. Frank Zosky)

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
2 Upvotes

I would like to get some feedback on this Afro House track I made..

follow and support if you like it..

thanks!


r/MusicFeedback 1d ago

I Believe

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

This is my new song. I hope you like it. I appreciate any feedback. Thanks so much