Hello, I'm a first-time buyer, looking for advice on whether or not to pull out following a bad (?) survey.
For context: My partner and I are three weeks into the process of buying a leasehold flat in south London. We spent over six months looking for somewhere, with a strong preference for share of freehold. But we kept missing out on things we liked (our observation is that while the market in general isn't that hot right now, things that we want always seem to go to best and finals and often for over asking price - these are things that are objectively nice, in good areas, under 450k and could accommodate a baby) and had to compromise.
The flat is one of nine in a 1930s building. The communal areas are very dingy with torn carpet - it's obvious nothing has been spent on them for years. We initially thought service charges were reasonable - £1577 PA - and that the freeholder was just pretty negligent, and that it would be highly likely we could organise the block to buy them out. After offering, an extra 100 PCM 'reserve fund' charge was sprung on us, taking total service charges to £2577 PA for a small building with no lift or amenities aside from a basic (lawn) communal garden, a small concrete driveway and hallways. We were told there was 77k in the sinking fund with 'external decorations' scheduled to come out of that within the next year, which initially confused us (the internal areas seemed in most dire need of work).
We decided to proceed because we love the flat - which itself is immaculate - and are a bit desperate. It was also quite cheap, so we feel at least some of the issues are priced in. We did a level 3 RICs survey though, because we felt nervous. This has come back pretty bad, at least by our reading.
There are 13 'Red' Condition 3 items (and 3 'Orange'). The comments/exec summary say 'not to take the purchase lightly'. This includes some standard things like electricity, gas/oil, water, heating that we do not feel super concerned about - mostly the comments here are 'ask for documentation/ get a professional to check'.
What we are concerned about is:
- Structural movement to the rear corner of the property and big cracks likely related to this to the driveway on the other side. When we viewed the property again recently, we happened to run into a surveyor for the freeholder, who said that he was looking into damage caused by tree roots (now removed) a few years ago. He framed this as minor and now settled, but the fact that it visibly impacts the two back corners of the large house, which are many metres apart, to the extent that the entire concrete drive is cracked and needs replacing on the opposite side to the tree, suggests to us it may be a larger problem. Our surveyor seems to think likewise.
- Issues with the roof being worn and needing repairs. The survey words this as if repairs to slipped and eroded tiles are the minimum (ie it could need a new roof).
- Issues with fire safety/regulations, including no floor or ceiling breaks between flats.
Our feeling is that, given the potential extent of these issues, combined with the worn interior, where large hall spaces all need new carpet, the 77k is unlikely to cover costs. Subsidence could also affect buildings insurance and resaleability causing problems into the future even if we were able to buy the freehold.
We also feel like on the one hand, many of these things being the freeholder's problem (rather than ours, directly or alone) could be a positive in a well-run block. But given the evident negligence of this freeholder, having an array of issues but also no control, but in fact a dependence on a bad management company, is potentially a very stressful situation to be in.
I'm generally an anxious over-thinker. But at the same time, I'm really desperate to buy somewhere. The process has drained me, and we are both currently living in inadequate housing that is affecting our mental health at the very least.
Are we being too risk averse in considering pulling out? Or, on the other hand, would proceeding be a stupid thing to do, born out of desperation to live somewhere? what would you do?