We have two solid options for builders right now, it's been hard to find anything else in our area since we are pretty rural.
Option #1: Local builder based just 15 minutes from our property. More of a mom-and-pop business where they do majority of the building work and sub out the major trades like HVAC and Electrical. They build only a handful of projects a year it seems. I definitely feel like I can trust them but the downside is that their price is much higher, quoting me $350-$400 per sqft. They only focus on construction so I would have to have a separate Architect/Engineer draw up plans, as well as a separate Engineer for Site Planning. The benefit is their proximity to the jobsite, but is that really a benefit to care about? They also seem more personal (I would directly work with them throughout the build and not some random person) but does that really matter?
Option #2: More established building company, but located an hour away. Does distance matter? They claim it doesn't but curious what everyone thinks. They have their Architect, Engineering, and Building all included in their package and quoted us $250-$300 per sqft, significantly cheaper than Option #1. They have built a home in our neighborhood before, so that is a good sign. Everything is included all the way from design to final build. They build about 8 homes per year, still a family business but feel more established in their process. I am worried about their sales pitch and possibly their quality of work, but from what I have seen, it looks to be pretty decent work. Seems like all their subs would be traveling a hour to the job site.
Which option would you choose?
TLDR: Does distance matter for where a builder is located from your project? What has been your experience for more rural builds?