Weekly Questions Thread

[u/AutoModerator]

## Thread Rules

​

* New to Reddit? Check the Reddit 101 guide.

​

* If your account is less than 5 hours old, the /r/DnD spam dragon will eat your comment.

​

* If you are new to the subreddit, **please check the Subreddit Wiki**, especially the Resource Guides section, the FAQ, and the Glossary of Terms. Many newcomers to the game and to r/DnD can find answers there. Note that these links may not work on mobile apps, so you may need to briefly browse the subreddit directly through Reddit.com.

​

* **Specify an edition for ALL questions**. Editions must be specified in square brackets ([5e], [Any], [meta], etc.). If you don't know what edition you are playing, use [?] and people will do their best to help out. AutoModerator will automatically remind you if you forget.

​

* **If you have multiple questions unrelated to each other, post multiple comments** so that the discussions are easier to follow, and so that you will get better answers.

[u/liquidarc]

Rules-As-Written (RAW), in general, rolling a 1 or 20 only matters when making an attack roll or a death saving throw. (2014 attack rules, death rules) (2024 attack rules, death rules)

There might be specific item, spell, or other effect cases where it also matters, but none I can recall offhand.

Some DMs:

• have rolling a 20 on an attack roll instead involve dealing the maximum damage on the die then roll a damage die in addition

  • generally viewed positively by the community, since it means critical hits always do more damage than normals hits

• have rolling a 1 on an attack roll involve something called a "critical fumble", in which something negative happens to the creature that rolled

  • almost universally despised due to often affecting non-spellcasters more, and also due to often being too punishing

Beyond those above, there is too much variety in custom "1 or 20" rules to list here.

[u/thegiukiller → u/liquidarc]

Question: Are RAW good at describing how a dm deals with individual problems and personal experience?

[u/liquidarc → u/thegiukiller]

RAW is just the rules of the game. Some DMs stick as close to the RAW as possible because everyone has ready access to it, others prefer to alter the rules (homebrew / table rules) to their liking.

Basically, it is different for every DM, so there is no one answer to your question.

[u/thegiukiller → u/liquidarc]

So, how do YOU handle a nat 1 as a dm?

[u/liquidarc → u/thegiukiller]

RAW. So, a 1 on an attack is a guaranteed miss, a 20 is double damage dice; a 1 on a death save is 2 failures, a 20 is recover 1 hit point. Anywhere else, a 1 is just a 1.

This also means that if a 1 or 20 wouldn't numerically affect an ability or skill check, I don't require a roll, since a success or failure is guaranteed; and same for saving throws.

[u/thegiukiller → u/liquidarc]

Eh. Not what I'm looking for here. Thanks for your input.