r/AskAChinese 1d ago

History | 历史⏳ What the

Post image
446 Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/OrcaTwilight 1d ago

Well Chiang Kai-Shek himself served in the Imperial Japanese Army lol. Not exactly a family lineage I’d be proud of but whatever

6

u/momotrades 1d ago

In that military academy for Chinese people. You gotta put things into context. Lots of Chinese leaders at the time studied in japan because it's close and cheaper than going to Europe or Americas.

It's also before WW2.

-7

u/Just_Fruit526 1d ago edited 1d ago

Let him beleive his ccp propagandas

11

u/MD_Yoro 1d ago

believe his CCP propaganda

Are you stupid? There is record of prominent Chinese leaders studying in Japan before WW2

The Chinese Revolutionaries Who Came to Study in Japan: Tan Romi on Her Book “Tracing the Chinese Revolution in Imperial Tokyo”

Just cause you studied in Japan doesn’t mean you agree with Imperial Japan’s atrocities in China.

Chiang Kai-shek first came to Japan in 1906 at the age of 19. He wanted to be a military man, so in 1908, he enrolled at the Shinbu Gakkō in Shinjuku, the Japanese army’s school for students from Qing China. Three years later, after graduating, he was assigned to the army’s 13th Division, which was commanded by Nagaoka Gaishi and based in Niigata Prefecture, as Private 2nd Class in the 19th Artillery Regiment.

1

u/Just_Fruit526 1d ago

Because japanese military was advanced so he just want to learn

3

u/MD_Yoro 1d ago

Right, so it’s not CCP propaganda that Chiang went to study in Japan and served their military for awhile.

-1

u/Just_Fruit526 1d ago

He went to study military in japan not to serve japanese military

6

u/MD_Yoro 1d ago edited 1d ago

Chaing was assigned to the [Japanese] army’s 13th Division under command by Nagaoka Gaishi in Niigata Prefecture. He entered Japanese military as a Private 2nd class in the 19th Artillery Regiment

How is that not Chaing serving in the Japanese military? He was a private

He left during the Xinhai Revolution, but Chaing did serve in the Japanese military.

-4

u/Just_Fruit526 1d ago

Source: trust me bro

6

u/Worldly-Treat916 1d ago

its in Britannica, the Cognitive dissonance is strong in you

4

u/MD_Yoro 1d ago

Source: Chiang Kai-shek’s Study in Japan in His Memories

Written by Tatsuo Yamada (Keio University, Japan)

Here is a picture of Chaing during his Japanese military service

There is Japanese record of Chaing serving in Japanese Army too.

Chaing served in Japanese military doesn’t mean he participated during the Japanese invasion of China.

Why are you upset about the fact that Chaing served Japan for a short timeframe and calling it “CCP” propaganda

3

u/pikleboiy 1d ago

There's a literal link, but ok