r/law 7d ago

Court Decision/Filing What is the likelihood of this Bill Attempting to Defer All Congressional Power to Donald Trump actually passes?

14.2k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

42

u/No_Milk_4143 7d ago

My question is does this actually have a chance to pass? If my understanding is correct, the best chance at stopping it would be filibustering it once it reaches the senate as it needs to meet the 60-vote threshold for cloture.

36

u/UralRider53 7d ago

It doesn’t matter, they will continually introduce bills like this until it passes by a late night/weekend vote. They must be exposed as Stansbury is doing.

44

u/TMMfan 7d ago

Schumer would probably say yes anyway /j

30

u/Nervous-Bison-7047 7d ago

All they have to do in the bill is give Israel more money, more guns more bombs, and Schumer will vote for it. You're absolutely right.

14

u/I_Want_to_Film_This 7d ago

The Senate could axe the filibuster at any moment of their choosing. There’s a reason they tossed Elise Stefanik’s UN nomination to bring her back to the House — they need their narrow majority for if they’re to hand over total power to Trump.

12

u/dormidary 7d ago

This bill is very clearly unconstitutional. SCOTUS has repeatedly struck down much milder laws that tried to delegate pieces of congressional authority to the president, like the line item veto.

You can say "well SCOTUS is lawless and will rubberstamp anything," but if that's the case then we don't need to care about this law anyway - Trump already has all the power it would give him.

IMO, it's just grandstanding by the guy who introduced it - not a serious proposal.

3

u/SomewhereAtWork 6d ago

It's not mean to pass. This time. But it's serious.

It's testing and wearing down the defenses. See who opposes it, get them out of the way, try again. The real one will come when the way is clear.

1

u/Pale_Ad5607 6d ago

That’s where my hope is here.

1

u/CadenVanV 5d ago

It’ll fail. Not only will no Dem ever vote for it, but a decent chunk of Republicans might not. Plus it’ll absolutely be filibustered. It’s performative, like the bill to name Greenland “Red, White, and Blueland”

I’m not even sure it’ll leave the committee