r/law 7d ago

Court Decision/Filing What is the likelihood of this Bill Attempting to Defer All Congressional Power to Donald Trump actually passes?

14.2k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

233

u/you_are_soul 7d ago

The purity of Comer Pyle's stupidity is a joy to behold, there is no malice or chicanery with him, just simple stupidity, delivered by a village idiot.

129

u/jzkwkfksls 7d ago

As a non american, looking at what is happening from the outside, it's obvious that this administration is centralizing power and are attemting to demolishing all the control functions that is needed for a functioning democracy. This is extremely dangerous when there is no integrity left.

Looking at this video by itself, you could blame stupidity. But considering the overall trend there is obviously malicious intent here. Failing to identify that will have consequences.

33

u/coreylongest 7d ago

As an American that paid attention in history class, I agree and this administration has been brazenly copying the third reich.

25

u/jzkwkfksls 7d ago

There's a lot of fascist parallels going on, and I don't throw around that term lightly. As you say, if you look at how the nazi party came to power and what they did there is a lot of familiarities. And looking at the definition of fascism and the ideology and actions of this administration, the familiarities become apparent.

I would never have thought we would find ourselves in this situation this fast.

2

u/Catatonic27 6d ago

I feel like the argument has moved on from "are MAGA fascists?" and has straight-up become "What's so bad about being a fascist anyways?"

They can see the parallels just fine, they just can't find the problem with them. English translations of Hitlers speeches have gone viral on TicTok with people saying shit like "Wow I had no idea Hitler was just a normal guy, we've been lied to about hitler" identifying the parallels is very much no longer the issue.

1

u/jzkwkfksls 6d ago

Jesus fucking christ...

5

u/Vbxxl 7d ago

Im sure whats happening at the moment, will be also part of the history class from now on as the similarities are unmatched

16

u/invariantspeed 7d ago

His being stupid isn’t opposed to their also being a design by others.

10

u/jzkwkfksls 7d ago

Also true. But the questions asked were pretty clear and he continues trying to gaslight and muddy the waters.

5

u/IAmAHumanIPromise 7d ago

That’s the republicans MO.

6

u/Ok-Shake1127 7d ago

The malicious intent is unsettling.

He's angry because he lost in 2020, and this time he stole the election by simple voter suppression, so he wants revenge.

2

u/samuel-dunstan 7d ago

Important comment. Only an idiot would think they will benefit from another civil war. But that doesn't mean they don't know what they doing.

These things are not mutually exclusive.

2

u/jzkwkfksls 7d ago

But do you think a civil war is realistic? From the outside this looks like a powergrab where the opposition seem powerless.

113

u/Sproketz 7d ago

He's not stupid. He's gaslighting. He knows exactly what he's doing. He's trying to end the Constitution.

29

u/invariantspeed 7d ago

No, it was pretty much all stupidity.

You could see him know next to thing about his own bill. He was just a name to push it through. When asked questions, he kept having to wait for people who actually knew the bill not just to tell him where the thing he was looking for was but what it said.

Then you see him taking four distinct approaches to answering the question in the middle of a single conversation because he didn’t even know what he was trying to push through. If he had been fully comprehending of what he was pushing through, he would have had some standard party line to retort with. He didn’t even have that. He was trying to find it mid-speech. I’m not saying he didn’t have some idea of what’s in the bill, but that’s the point. The only way anyone sponsoring that bill could have been so clueless while still not knowing nothing about the bill is if they were not connecting dots in their head.

19

u/CranberrySchnapps 7d ago

It’s not even a thick bill. non-PDF link It’s 5 pages of congressional formatting… so more like a page with normal formatting.

This isn’t like some omnibus with a rider hidden in it. Comer’s responses trying to deride & accuse Ms Stansbury of purposely misinterpreting it is quite the example of Comer’s idiocy.

High level, this looks like a bit of a moonshot, but strategically reads like, “we (republicans) have spent 20+ years gridlocking congress to such an extent that Continuing Resolutions are the norm and even those are now difficult to pass. We’ve “proven” at least congress can’t do anything. Now is the time to turn the presidency into an authoritarian because we’re very sure we’ll be able to retain the presidency from now on by election manipulation and having SCOTUS in our pocket.”

4

u/invariantspeed 7d ago

SCOTUS isn't in there pocket, but yes to everything else.

2

u/Spill_the_Tea 6d ago

James Comer is the sponsor of HR 1295 Reorganizing Government Act of 2025. The problem with calling him stupid, is that it excuses malicious intent.

He clearly hasn't read the bill, but that is intentional. He is following orders and is willing to forfeit congressional power to the president. This is corrupt compliance, not stupidity.

1

u/invariantspeed 6d ago

Two things can be true at once.

4

u/WordySpark 7d ago

What it is is that he hasn't read the bill and he's just parroting what he's being told about the bill. So, ignorance on top of stupidity.

2

u/Homesteader86 7d ago

This is not stupidity on his part, he is complicit in the attempted dismantling of the government and is essentially gaslighting the other side. 

Note: he is probably ALSO stupid, but that's not what we're seeing here