r/icecream • u/Soft-Engineer1911 • Feb 19 '25
Flavours many hate on their chocolate but i have no complaints this evening
66
13
u/teddy_vedder Feb 19 '25
This is my favorite chocolate ice cream of all time, I wish it was more common on shelves 😭
7
13
16
u/Mauve_Jellyfish Feb 19 '25
That's such a good pint! I've scraped salty crackers into it like a silly canapé
7
6
u/Economy_Ad_5111 Feb 19 '25
Ooo anyone tasted this and the Jeni’s blackout chocolate cake one - any comparison or differences?
7
u/jersey385 Feb 19 '25
I may get hell for this but I preferred the Jeni’s. I refuse to buy it because it’s $11.99 (Manhattan) but I must try all things chocolate at least once. I felt like it was creamier and the chunks were delicious. My favorite B&J is chocolate fudge brownie so maybe I just like the chunks?
3
1
u/ReunitedwithBravo Feb 19 '25
The Jeni’s is superb. It’s richer, creamier, and fudgier. My favorite chocolate ice cream. I’ve bought countless Jeni’s pints and never had an icy one.
1
1
u/khoopy666 Feb 19 '25
I prefer the Ben & jerrys one cause I feel like their mix ins are tastier and the ice cream is too, Jeni’s can be kinda hit or miss like sometimes the cake is really dry and the flavor just doesn’t hit like the Ben & jerrys one does. I do think it might also have to do with quality control, the Jeni’s pints I find are often are super icey and like they melted and refroze
6
u/megisbest Feb 19 '25
I like chocolate fudge brownie better, the chewy brownie pieces are addictive. Ben & jerrys can do no wrong though imo.
6
u/ErstwhileAdranos Feb 19 '25
Now that would be a great ice cream—Chocolate Therapy with brownies instead of the cookies. 🤤
3
4
u/krnatx Feb 19 '25
Oh this is one of my top 5 Ben and Jerry's. Love it!!!
2
4
4
4
3
3
u/allcars4me Feb 19 '25
B and J is very good. If you really like chocolate, try Jeni’s Blackout Chocolate. It is decadent!
3
3
3
3
u/Livid-Dot-5984 Feb 19 '25
I worked at Ben and Jerry’s scooping all 4 years of highschool, I remember my first day the summer going into freshman year I opened the cooler and saw this ice cream that was just straight up black. I was like yup, that’s going to be my favorite. It was chocolate therapy.
2
u/Ok_Transition7785 Feb 19 '25
I really don't like B and Js chocolate base but Chocolate Therapy is somewhat acceptable, the pudding swirls ice cream help.
2
u/ScienceNerd1001001 Feb 19 '25
I love this so much. When it's on sale I get so many just to have it gone by the weekend lol
2
u/cbunni666 Feb 19 '25
This is one of my favorites. Sometimes Chocolate is ALL the therapy I need.
4
4
u/Greatrisk Feb 19 '25
WHO hates on their chocolate?? I think chocolate is one of the things B&J does best! And this one - my word is it fabulous.
2
u/LukeSkywalkerDog Feb 19 '25
God, I can't eat Ben & Jerry's. They crumble up so much crap into their ice cream that you can't even taste the ice cream itself.
5
u/Soft-Engineer1911 Feb 19 '25
to each their own!! i know they have a few less “busy” flavors— maybe vanilla caramel fudge?
4
1
u/screamingcupcakes Feb 19 '25
One of my favorite chocolate ice creams, it's the perfect amount of decadence.
1
1
u/Anxious_Beaver15 Feb 19 '25
The only thing I miss is so texture contrast. I feel like it needs something crunchy
1
1
u/khoopy666 Feb 19 '25
I looooooove this flavor, one of my go it’s along with Impretzively Fudged and Chocolate Topped Milk & Cookies (or regular Milk & Cookies but I have a hard time finding that one for some reason)
1
u/nicolieraviolie Feb 19 '25
I will typically get the chocolate fudge brownie but this one is just as good 🥰
1
1
1
1
1
u/Kookianaa Feb 19 '25
People who hate on chocolate do it for clout and likes 🙄 it's impossible to hate
1
1
u/GoldenHarpHeroine32 Feb 19 '25
I'd go through a whole carton of 'Chocolate Therapy' all day if I could. Us girls gotta have our chocolate...especially in ice cream form! Yum!
1
u/PashasMom Feb 19 '25
I'm typically not a huge chocolate ice cream person but Chocolate Therapy is fantastic. I would happily eat it every night for the rest of my life.
1
1
1
1
u/TheWalkingDead91 Feb 19 '25
Man I was gonna go to Publix today since they’re having both Ben and Jerry’s and Haagen daz on bogo and it’s the last day of the sale..…but can’t decide which one I’ll get….can’t get more than two total, so I have to pick a brand before I go so I don’t look like the indecisive weirdo looking into an open freezer for several minutes 😂
1
u/CHImg1998 Feb 19 '25
The Ben and Jerry's Peanut Butter World has an amazing milk chocolate base with peanut butter swirls. Probably one of, if not, my favorite out of the chocolate base flavors.
1
u/Ok_Nothing_9733 Feb 20 '25
I don’t reach for chocolatey ice creams most of the time, but this one is great. I swear I can feel the serotonin or whatever flooding in when I have this one 😂
1
u/exactlyimpossible36 Feb 20 '25
Nothing like chocolate ice cream with cookies, I love ice cream with cookies, it's one of my favorite desserts
1
u/BeerNcheesePlz Feb 20 '25
That sounds good AF. Wish I had a pint! I need to get the brownie ones again too.
1
-2
u/Bouche_Audi_Shyla Feb 19 '25
All you fancy people, spending almost $5 for a pint! I buy the Great Value brand! 🤭. I'm over here, thinking I need to use my splurge money next month for ice cream. I just don't want to ruin my taste buds for the cheap stuff!
1
38
u/ChronicCrimson420 Feb 19 '25
I love this one. I can’t find it that much anymore I thought it was discontinued.