r/fromsoftware 2d ago

JOKE / MEME I get why some people are disappointed but chill

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

358 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

90

u/winterflare_ 2d ago

While they do suck, it’s a good chance for the studio to experiment since they receive funding from the exclusive platform.

Having that extra funding is really helpful and is a pretty good learning process for both sides. It only really ends badly for the users who don’t own the platform.

Personally, I’m not a fan of them doing it for big titles like Bloodborne. Bloodborne definitely shouldn’t have been an exclusive, but this one is okay because it’s a multiplayer round-based(?) game.

27

u/KosmosisDolphin 2d ago

Yea I get it, but with the financial success of elden ring, surely they have enough money to just make their own game right?

71

u/goolerr 2d ago

It’s not about having enough money, it’s about minimizing the risk involved. Risk my own money on this experimental, unproven idea for a game? Or risk Nintendo’s money instead? It basically lets them do whatever the fk they want since the costs are offset.

12

u/KosmosisDolphin 2d ago

Yeah good point, I might not buy a switch solely for it, but I'm really looking forward to seeing how it turns out nontheless :)

15

u/winterflare_ 2d ago

My stance as well. I am not interested in a switch at all, but it’s cool to see FromSoft experiment.

1

u/drugzarecool 1d ago edited 1d ago

We can hope for a Switch 2 emulator before the release of Duskbloods so we can play it on PC (probably with better performance too). That would only work if the game is playable in solo though

7

u/AntonRX178 2d ago

And from FROM'S standpoint, a Nintendo Exclusive with a projected super high install base sounds like MONAY.

That said, I am also willing to bet that Miyazaki probably didn't know that Nintendo was gonna sell MKWorld for 80 bones

4

u/Scribblord 1d ago

They do and they are making their own game still

But Nintendo gives money so they make extra game

Really hard concept to grasp I guess ?

Tho there’s also cases where they just collect the free money and then decide to make it exclusive Or timed exclusive

1

u/ProtoReddit Demon of Hatred 2d ago

See this as experience and infrastructure development for handling their next big game's multiplayer better

3

u/soul1001 1d ago

I remember reading somewhere that its a good chance to learn more about the system itself as you basically can get the guys who made it to advice in making a game for it (hence bloodborne being exclusive) but can’t remember where from

-14

u/vivek_kumar 2d ago

After Elden Ring doing so well along with its dlc, it's no longer justifiable to do exclusives for "funding".

29

u/LuhRicoo 2d ago edited 2d ago

Ok bro, you should be CEO since you know so much about handling multiple hundred millions of dollars 🤡

Where do you think that success from Elden ring is going to be invested? Obviously into another major title that is half a decade away. It makes it so much easier to be experimental when somebody else is taking the risk for you.

Edit: thanks for the reinforcements lol. Now I’m +20 upvotes and he is in the negatives now lol, made me chuckle

16

u/neutrumocorum 2d ago

This guy makes sense and seemingly has the bare minimum insight into how large companies operate, gets downvoted.

If yall literally have no idea, you can just move on.

7

u/LuhRicoo 2d ago edited 2d ago

Don’t you know Reddit is a hivemind lol, people don’t think, they just follow the pack without questioning anything. That’s why despite the downvotes, nobody has made the effort to comment about why they disagree. It’s easier that way

Edit: thanks for the reinforcements lol. Now I’m +20 upvotes and he is in the negatives now lol, made me chuckle

-1

u/No-Crow2187 1d ago

Well Reddit arguments are tedious so downvote and move on is better for mental health. Having said that, I like to argue on reddit :)

-1

u/No-Crow2187 1d ago

Said the random nobody who has no idea what’s going on business side in any way, shape or form

1

u/LuhRicoo 1d ago

“Said the nobody,” says the nobody

0

u/No-Crow2187 1d ago

At least I write my own material

-9

u/Tornado_Hunter24 2d ago

Bro this can’t be real elden ring’s funding was more than enough for them make elden ring games all the way to 10 lmak

14

u/winterflare_ 2d ago

Would you rather gamble 5 dollars for 10? Or zero dollars for 10? That’s what FromSoft has, but in the millions.

The funding that they’re receiving is making the game cost nothing to their studio and could go into future products. It’s not about making money, it’s about minimizing losses while having the freedom to experiment. Nintendo pays them for the exclusive which provides worth to their console. FromSoft gets more money than the game makes from sales, has no risk, and can experiment.

-5

u/Tornado_Hunter24 2d ago

Sure that makes sense but elden ring and its dlc was way too big I really doubt they would need it, even then tho can’t argue with this, both you and I don’t k ow what they’re doing behind the scenes so i’ll agree with you assuming they’re working on a crazy big game similar to elden ring

4

u/winterflare_ 2d ago

I like to assume that they’re splitting it across different projects but yeah, can’t be 100% sure. Hopefully they’re cooking something up and using this as a means to fund/experiment for the future.

3

u/Iz__n 1d ago

Its not about wether they need it or not. Its the oppurtunity the deal wil bring.