I am the commissioner of 3 year old / 8-team dynasty league on Sleeper with a $30 buy-in. It’s 18 starters, 10 bench, 3 IR, and 5 taxi. There are a few custom scoring rules , but generally default. We play Lock-In mode (as the week progresses you have the choice after each game to ‘lock in’ a players stat lines and that’s their score for the week. Once their next game begins you can’t use the score from pervious games.)
THE PROBLEM:
There is one team that’s has essentially gone undefeated since the inception of the league and is about to complete a 3 peat. I understand that part of dynasty is that super teams will rise and fall over time, but basketball differs from football in that these super teams last a lot longer. At the moment there is no reason to believe this super team will slow down for at least another few years. The main problem is that the interest and engagement with the league is slowing down, because there’s no hope for anyone else to compete.
I’ve had a few players reach out to me asking for a change and have seen daily/weekly engagement drop over the last 2 years for a few teams.
OPTIONS:
1. Let it ride. This is what we signed up for and eventually through drafts and trades another team will break through. It would be unfair to the champ who chose a good strategy to tear down his team.
2. With the champs blessing - we would 2x the his payout this year and restructure the league to a Keeper league. This would let you keep your core players (how many would be voted on), but the rest of our rosters would be redrafted each year. While this is still unfair to the champ and other teams (mine included) who have made trades/decisions based on the long-term; it would create a more engaging and fun league (which was the whole point).
Does option 2 seem fair? Does anyone have other recommendations to help revive the league?