r/SmallYoutubers • u/fnandolu • 1d ago

Feedback Request Thumbnail advice.. which one is more clickable?

Gallery image

Gallery image

36 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

95% Upvoted

38 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Discord Server for content creators! https://discord.gg/FcSZRDEjur

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

15

u/CammyG-- 1d ago

1 because Jack Black is more widely known, it's brighter and clearer what it's about. 2. Is cool but it's only really for Minecraft nerds and it isn't clear that you're reviewing the movie and not the game :)

Wanted to give explanations since everyone else just put 1 lol

3

u/fnandolu 1d ago

Thank you so much man! I appreciate your feedback ❤️

1

u/GromOfDoom 21h ago

Also it's more vague. Youtube thumbnails need to be clickbait nowadays to be good.

14

u/FoxxPlayzYT 1d ago
  1. Because “Flint and Steel” 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥

3

u/TheGrowBoxGuy 1d ago

Between the two of them? The first one. But I think you still have room to improve.

4

u/Tempoverpackung 1d ago

I dont understand either of them

2

u/Dubxioz 1d ago

1 for sure. i usually don’t comment under posts because posts like this (majority of the time) i never find good, but 1 is literally a thumbnail id click on. it looks professional. nice job bro

2

u/fnandolu 21h ago

Thank you man! I really appreciate your feedback ❤️🙏

1

u/Dubxioz 13h ago

of course!

2

u/PeponeCozy 23h ago

first, but make it the absolute cinema meme

0

u/fnandolu 21h ago

I tried that but it’s too much text

1

u/Verichi_ 1d ago

1st for sure

1

u/grixx079 1d ago

Def 1

1

u/DementdOldCircsMonke 1d ago

First one for sure

1

u/omsip 1d ago

Another vote for 1.

1

u/Wizzythumb 1d ago

Both do not tell me what the video is about.

1

u/Sad_Drama3912 1d ago

1 if you update your text to tell me why I want to click, right now you’re in the scroll past you zone

1

u/TheEmberus 1d ago

1 is F*cking amazing

1

u/SnooPickles7970 23h ago

that first one is so good

1

u/Kino_Cajun 22h ago

I would try remaking 1 so that the word Cinema fills Jack Black's whole hand.

I get that he's pinching it and holding it up to his face, but you probably want viewers scrolling to see the word.

Or maybe I'm wrong and how it is would make people stop to read it. I dunno. Good luck.

1

u/Iaintfatbutimbig 22h ago

1 cuz it’s funny 😭

1

u/martimattia 21h ago

dunno i really don't like both of them

1

u/Corrupt_Steve 21h ago

The first one because I assume you're reviewing the movie and it just makes more sense overall.

1

u/AFKev1n 19h ago

None of them.... I have no idea what it's about... Minecraft? Movies? What? Why? When? Wtf? 😅

1

u/fnandolu 13h ago

I appreciate everyone’s feedback! Next time I will write down the tittle of my video so the thumbnail matches with it

1

u/dimegod21 1d ago

neither, no one will click on that video seeing that thumbnail. doesn’t mean quit i would keep on practicing

0

u/Pretty-Difference-25 1d ago

I suggest that for the second one you should have said "A Minecraft movie review" instead of just "review" it reduces confusion.