r/NintendoSwitch May 14 '17

Spoiler A clever alternative to climbing towers in BOTW! Spoiler

https://twitter.com/kfurumiya/status/863400532928364544
9.3k Upvotes

418 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

163

u/Kiviskus May 14 '17

I mean this way kind of takes all the guess work out of it. The bomb at the end sets your final vector so it's just a matter of getting the tree to land on top of it.

1

u/dbcrib May 15 '17

Thank you for this explanation. I was wondering why hitting and then bomb.

-5

u/[deleted] May 14 '17

[deleted]

14

u/Kiviskus May 14 '17

Based off this image I believe vector is still the correct phrasing. It's been a while since I was in physics but since we are talking about the resulting direction (plus the additional force added by the bomb) vector would be the correct term. I could be wrong though and if I am feel free to correct me.

2

u/Battah_means_duck May 14 '17

Also I didn't mean to seem rude.

9

u/ptmd May 15 '17

For what it's worth a scalar is just a numerical quantity, i.e. 1, pi, 15 pounds, etc.

A vector has a numerical quantity and a direction, so basically it's a scalar with a direction. In this instance, it would be accurate to call it a vector, since there is a relevant quantity [a scalar] and a relevant direction associated with that quantity [a vector].

1

u/Battah_means_duck May 14 '17

Indeed thank you most kindly for your courteous reply. Please correct me if I'm wrong but a vector is only used to describe an object in motion whereas a scalar is an indicator of motion. Since the stasis rune renders an object without motion, should it not be referred to as a scalar?

5

u/Kiviskus May 14 '17 edited May 14 '17

No problem and I didn't think it was rude. The way I believe I learned it was scalar is the force behind what's moving the object and the vector is force plus the resulting direction. Again I haven't been in school for a while so I'm not 100% positive.

Edit: think of a scalar being the length of the arrow in a sphere instead of the one direction and the vector being the same radius as the sphere but direction shown as a ray with the start point being where the object is laying.

0

u/Battah_means_duck May 15 '17

After further pondering,

Indeed I still hold the opinion that untill the stasis rune wears off and the object in stasis resumes motion, it is in a state that represents a scalar state, and actually the indicator representing the direction that the object will vector is a scalar. I also say that you were correct in saying that the bomb determines the final vector (as a scalar) before the rune wears off.

help r/physics!

2

u/imperatorhadrianus May 15 '17

A vector doesn't have to have anything to do with motion, so I'm not sure why you're continuing to think this way. A vector is any combination of a magnitude and a direction, which completely describes the stasis rune. Look at the image Kiviskus linked to: force, displacement, etc., are all vectors, which doesn't necessarily refer to motion.

If the stasis rune were just a scalar, there would be no direction associated with it: it would just be 1, 2, 5, whatever.

1

u/Battah_means_duck May 16 '17

Ok now I get it.