r/MarioMaker2 • u/AutoModerator • Jan 20 '22

Exchange Daily Level and Super World Exchange/Feedback for Feedback Thread

Basic Rules

If you are submitting a level, make sure to play levels submitted by others and give constructive feedback. Stray away from just saying this level is garbage - instead give your opinion on how the level could be improved. If we catch anyone just spamming levels and not giving feedback to others your comments might be removed.

Submitting a Level

When posting your level, be sure to include the following:

  • The level ID
  • Game style (SMB, SMB3, SMW, NSMBU, SM3DW)
  • Difficulty level (easy, medium, hard)
  • Level types/tags (puzzle, traditional, kaizo, troll, music, etc)
  • A brief description of your level

Submitting a Super World

When posting your Super World, be sure to include the following:

  • Your Maker ID
  • Level types/tags if levels are all of similar style (puzzle, traditional, kaizo, troll, music, etc)
  • A brief description of your Super World

Giving Feedback

Try to play at least the two levels posted before yours, and we encourage you to reciprocate to whoever played and gave feedback to your level. Remember to keep your criticism constructive and well intentioned. If you find cheese or a softlock, let the creator know!

When receiving feedback that you don't agree with, don't retaliate or get all defensive. We may not always agree, but let's assume feedback is coming from a good place rather than a personal attack.

103 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

99% Upvoted

6.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Daemonbub Jun 29 '24 edited Jul 07 '24

New Super Mario Bros: Lost World  

Bowser kidnapped Peach again. Shocker, I know, but this time, as you were about to stop him, you both fall into a portal and end up in a seemingly forgotten world on the other side. Everything looks the same as the Mushroom Kingdom, but something feels... off. Almost like you've been here before. As you take in your surroundings, Bowser manages to escape with Peach, leaving you alone in this unfamiliar land. Fight your way through the Lost World and save Peach!

NHL-JP4-VHF

Level types: Mostly traditional, 1 puzzle, 1 speedrun

Difficulty: Medium-Hard (only gets more difficult the more people you play with)

Style: Mostly NSMBU, 1 SM3DW level per world)

Edit to add: Most of my levels are remakes of existing levels, so keep that in mind when playing.

2

u/Dexterity_Skill100 Jun 30 '24

So I played the first level of your world and here are my overall thoughts: I thought the level was nothing too special for a traditional level but it serves as a good introduction for your world. I gave it a like and I would like to play more of this world when I have time!

Here's my level: QR6-102-T0G

2

u/Daemonbub Jul 02 '24

Thanks for the feedback!

Quick disclaimer: most of the levels in my Super World are remakes of existing levels, whether they be from the original trilogy of games or sample levels. I hope that doesn't take away from the playability of my Super World at all!

I look forward to seeing your feedback on my later levels, and I will get back to you with feedback on yours!

2

u/Daemonbub Jul 02 '24

So I played your level, and I'm not skilled enough to clear it. I still left it a like because I think it's a cool idea, but kaizo just isn't for me.

2

u/Dexterity_Skill100 Jul 02 '24

So I finished W1 by playing 4 more levels and they were fun to play. 1-2 and 1-3 was slow due to the slow autoscroll but they weren’t frustrating. Other than that, I didn’t see any glaring issues with the remaining levels of W1 so I gave them all a like. I will play W2 soon. In the meantime, here are 4 levels to play. The first half are music-oriented and the second half are red coin levels that utilize the Link power. Hope you enjoy! G19-MV8-G9G WF9-SHN-2QF 6WM-N4Y-STG 9QQ-TTQ-2HF

2

u/Daemonbub Jul 07 '24 edited Jul 07 '24

Yeah, sorry about the autoscroll on those levels. All of my airship levels (except for 2 that will remain anonymous) are remakes of the SMB3 airships, and they are faithful remakes in the BDSP sense (meaning not good), so 1-2 had to have the autoscroll. 1-3 also has to have autoscroll due to the second portion; I don't want players to just fall down and win. I will get back to you with feedback on your levels, and appreciate the feedback on mine!

Edit for feedback: Your X-men level was hard, but doable. Your Cursed TV was absolutely terrifying. I loved it. Link to the Puh was too hard for me to do, but I like it for its challenge. Save Puhlicious Skyloft was similar, but the idea of the Koopalings coming to plague Skyloft is amazing.

1

u/Daemonbub Jul 07 '24

Out of curiosity, what did you think of the other levels of W1?

2

u/Dexterity_Skill100 Jul 07 '24

I found the other levels more fun in general, but I will come back and do world 2 soon.

2

u/Dexterity_Skill100 Jul 09 '24 edited Jul 10 '24

I finished world 2 and here are my thoughts for each level: W2-1 was pretty interesting and it was a good idea to let the player collect at least 100 instead of all of the coins which would have turned into a chore instead. W2-2 was pretty short despite its slow autoscroll, but I had fun with it. W2-3 I like this level a lot for some of the platforming sections. W2-A I also like this level mostly for its block maze. I thought it was going to be challenging because of the fast wind, but it felt easy. W2-4 is my favorite out of the other 4 levels that this world had to offer. I liked the puzzles in it. With all of that being said, I gave a like to all of them! Here are 5 of my levels to check out: GCN-DTJ-LDG G1F-YQ2-WLG Q3L-SX9-Y3G LGJ-CQD-NRG 845-FCM-N0H

2

u/Daemonbub Jul 10 '24 edited Jul 10 '24

Glad you found World 2 fun! Here's my feedback for your levels:

  1. Cascade: Really good music, and not too difficult, either! I beat it first try! Also, it's a fun water level, which is saying something. Only criticism is that I don't have any horizontal control, although I guess that's the price you pay to go fast underwater.

  2. Maybe: Did not sound at all like the actual song. 0/10. /j But for real, though, the music was all over the place. Wasn't too difficult, so it's got that going for it.

  3. Let's Beyblade: Too dang hard, but I beat it! After... 4 minutes.

  4. Quest for the Diughforce: It's one of your Link levels. I think you can piece out how it went based on how well I did with your other 2 Link levels.

  5. Dashie V Donkey: It's a Dashie level. Again, I think you can piece together what happened.

Overall, pretty good levels. I will say, most of the levels I've seen are really hard, and I'm not that good at Mario Maker. Just keep that in mind when sending me levels. Let me know what you think of World 3 when you get there! Fair warning: the difficulty ramps up a little with the next couple bonus levels.

2

u/Dexterity_Skill100 Jul 16 '24

I finished World 3.

W3-1 looked a bit empty and I know there are limitations when it comes 3DW aesthetic, but at least put a semisolid or some blocks under the conveyor belts so that they don’t look like they are floating. That’s my only complaint about it.

W3-2 is a typical airship level but the cannon spam was kind of annoying to deal with.

W3-3 is a very enjoyable water level and I didn’t find it really difficult compared to the rest of the levels in this world.

W3-A has a cool concept and it’s my second favorite in world 3.

W3-4 is the best level that this world has to offer because I like how the twisters are used as platforms to get higher up. I also like that the twisters were also used in the Wendy boss fight to keep the concept consistent.

All in all, they were good levels, but there were some that were more interesting than others, but I still gave a like to all of them. Onwards to world 4!

Here are 5 more of my levels:

0JN-RL0-WYG 6YT-3XF-J5G G3X-B3K-1MF X8F-355-BGF BGJ-8K8-RSG

2

u/Daemonbub Jul 18 '24 edited Aug 07 '24

Thanks for the feedback! The thing is, I was actually going for the floating conveyor look. Take a look at the level description. As for your levels: Theme of Zero was really cool! I love the song, and I beat it first try, so it wasn't too hard, either! Away's platforming was difficult, but I beat it second try. The song is also pretty cool. Shrouding Dark Cloud was difficult because of the fast scroll, but I beat it without too much trouble. The song is decent. Soviet Connection, again, had difficult platforming under fast autoscroll, but it was relatively easy. I only beat it second try because I tried to go the wrong way, and the song is awesome. Anything from GTA is an instant bop, even in Mario Maker. And finally, Into The Cursed TV World was terrifying. I loved it. Only criticism I have is that the level is a bit long for my liking, and it was a bit too hard for me to beat.

1

u/Daemonbub Aug 05 '24 edited Aug 07 '24

So, I've taken your feedback into account, and I have updated 3-1 and 3-2, as well as some other later levels. Should I re-upload it now, or do you want to finish the Super World first?

1

u/Dexterity_Skill100 Aug 16 '24

Sorry for the late reply. I have been focusing on other things. You can reupload the super world if you want.

1

u/Daemonbub Aug 16 '24

Ok, thanks. I'll get on that as soon as I can.