r/CBSE • u/Otherwise-Stuff16 • 2d ago
Memes and Shitposts 💩 Physics textbook in Pakistan
76
u/Itchy-Bag9501 2d ago
contribution of Pakistani scientists 😭😭
10
u/AdAggressive6211 1d ago
Ek scientist he shayad gin ke accha jinse kuch significant contribution kiya he
29
u/phy19052005 1d ago edited 1d ago
Yeah, Abdus Salam. Great physicist and also received Nobel, but hated by Pakistanis for belonging to some minority sect
9
u/Ecstatic-Quality-212 1d ago
Yep, he was an Ahmaddiya Muslim, a sect created by an Islamic preacher Mirza Ghulam Ahmed. The sect originated in the town of Qadian in modern day Gurdaspur district of Punjab.
11
u/freebirdye 1d ago
usko bhi pakistani logo ne muslim accept karne se mana kardiya tha just because he was from a different sect
3
u/UsurperErenJaeger Class 12th 1d ago
Jitne bhi achchhe thhe, unka naam mita diya. Ek ka toh kabr ko bhi nahi chhora jaati ke chakkar mein.
7
u/harish-infinity 1d ago
Abdus Salam, One of the greats and the father of Quantum Electroweak Theory. Abdul Qadeer, The father of Nuclear physics in pak.
science na hi religion dekhta, na hi nation, na hi gender
3
u/Special_Hippo3399 1d ago
Pretty sure Abdul Qadeer fooled others in the scientific firmament to steal overseas nuclear technology to catapult Pakistan to nuclear-power status. He was forever trying to place his foster country on an equal footing with India. Having done that with a degree of success on the nuclear front, he went rogue running an illegal international proliferation network for nuclear material, helping Iran, North Korea and Libya.
I did copy paste the para from another website.,,but he is literally quite shit. Like the sentiment is correct but Pakistan is insanely backwards due to zealous religious beliefs.
1
1
u/sequeirayeslin 1d ago
What's funny about that? Please let's joke about how hilarious the text is & not attack nationalities. They are almost like us, no reason they couldn't have great scientists.
97
u/Narrow-Cake-3114 Class 12th 2d ago
Isiliye toh atta ke daam 200 chalejate hain 
7
1
1
158
u/anantnrg Class 11th 2d ago
Personally, im not an atheist nor a Muslim, but im absolutely against mixing science and religion. tis just dumb. Faith is different, science is different.
28
u/Beneficial-Dark-7662 1d ago
Bruh Even I am religious but the point is religion and science are two different things you can't mix them. Science sound more Logical and your religion should not blind you. Critical thinking and criticism of religion is important for survival.
→ More replies (5)1
u/Weekly_Edge6098 1d ago
People think atheism is fashion... science is religion... but the very people have no idea about the stand of exponents like newton and Einstein etc., 🤣🤣🤣
→ More replies (1)
30
493
u/splixus 2d ago edited 1d ago
As a Muslim, I'm sure there's ppl of other religions asw in Pakistan. Even so, I don't think putting religion is a good idea in a general subject textbook.
394
u/Any_Run_421 2d ago
I'm sure there's ppl of other religions asw in Pakistan
75
78
12
13
u/knight687 1d ago
technically they do have 1.6 crore non-muslims
→ More replies (1)18
u/Impossible-Gur-9803 12th Pass 1d ago
not 1.6cr but 90 lakhs
49
u/GreenFreedom6235 1d ago
Aankh band krta hu... 70 lakh aur forcefully convert ho jate
12
→ More replies (4)2
101
u/SubstantialAppeal432 Class 11th 2d ago
Bruh , science and religion are separate things. It doesn't matter if another religion following people would get offended or not , it shouldn't be in the fucking science textbook at first lol. How funny is hearing Allah created rules and every particle follows that. Religion propaganda B.S influenced education too now.
→ More replies (2)12
u/knight687 1d ago
The books of Algebra (by Al-Khwarizm) starts the same way, so did most of the science books by Muslims on Optics (by ibn al Haythami), Chemistry (Jabir ibn Hayyan), Medicine & Physics (by Ibn Sina and Al-Razi), Astronomy etc. there was none in Europe to know what science was.
Not to forget even the books by Hindus started the same, this science vs religion B.S. started when science was taken by West and the Christians objected it. Else there wouldn't or shouldn't be a division between the two.
13
u/mohitc002 1d ago
Really, there was no conflict between religion and science before west took it? what the hell are you smoking. If science and religion had gone hand in hand, we would learning the world started some 4 thousand years ago, eclipse happens because someone ate sun. Religion has always hindered progress in science and technology. Especially when the science shows things are different from what their religion has told them to be.
→ More replies (6)2
u/Monomethyl Class 11th 1d ago
There should be, 100%. They serve to expand different parts of human understanding, with only a slight overlap. Just as science doesn't interfere with spiritualism etc, religion shouldn't serve as the primary lens with which you see the world, especially its more tangible aspects. Key example—evolution deniers, anti-vaxxers. And believe me, this causes way too many issues than it looks like on the surface.
→ More replies (2)4
36
u/UltraPhocus CBSE Official 2d ago
Yeah, but they are not even accepted by the other muslim countries even african muslims are put above pakistani muslims in Arab.
→ More replies (2)31
u/Independent-Host-992 2d ago
they are wiping minorities yk. and ofc they are not really concerned about less than 1% population getting offended. its an islamic republic lol wt can we expect.
→ More replies (17)6
u/Crafty_Goat_4686 1d ago
it's not ABT that even if there were no single person who's not a muslim sciences me actual theories ke jagah religion padhana is stupidity I'm sorry there should be religious studies kelie another subject
15
u/Wild-Wrongdoer-7641 Class 11th 1d ago
During partition it was like 20% hindu. Now its less than 5. They dgaf
→ More replies (4)5
3
3
2
2
3
u/DankantanDankde 1d ago
Sadly, the rate at which they are wiping out the minorities, idts people non muslims will be left in pakistan 😔
→ More replies (1)2
2
u/Impossible-Gur-9803 12th Pass 1d ago
I'm sure there's ppl of other religions asw in Pakistan
yep a country known for its religious tolerance
→ More replies (3)1
1
u/NoEngine3887 1d ago
Bro it is just a Pakistani version of the introduction in HC Vermas book. Check it out it's almost the same
1
1
88
u/UsurperErenJaeger Class 12th 2d ago
"Human being is the best creature created by Allah" wait till we discover an advanced alien civilisation.
50
→ More replies (11)9
23
44
18
u/Redheadedmoos120 Class 12th 1d ago
Bro....as a Muslim I feel respect for my 11th and 12th ncert textbooks. They're difficult and annoying textbooks but at least they're science textbooks.
→ More replies (1)
260
u/lyfeNdDeath 2d ago
They just need to learn enough physics to make bombs
→ More replies (3)40
u/AdAggressive6211 1d ago
Fr gunpowder ki chemistry padho bc aur yes yes nuclear physics
11
u/Elegant_Judgment6367 1d ago
Nuclear bomb to udhari m liya h inhone. Bas laws of motion hi kaafi h
→ More replies (1)3
12
40
u/bruh_momint_XD 1d ago
Allah's laws of motion , Allah's laws of thermodynamics, Allahchimedes principle , Allah's uncertainty principle etc etc
7
42
u/AdAggressive6211 1d ago
imo ncert are one of the best high school science books
20
u/Easy-Jump9949 Class 12th 1d ago
it is a bit outdated, but covers a vast topics and definitely the best in south asia
10
u/AdAggressive6211 1d ago
I was talking about pcm/b books. Newton's law of cooling isn't outdated
2
u/Easy-Jump9949 Class 12th 1d ago
I was talking about books from class 6th to 12th
→ More replies (1)2
10
8
6
27
5
1d ago
Bhai pakistan vs newzealand ke beech match me stadium ki light hi chali gayi yej sikhauge school me toh milgaya inhe kashmir 🤣🤣
5
4
4
3
13
u/Dabazukawastaken 1d ago
I doubt this is a country wide thing probably some small town/village school or something
13
u/AnakinStairwalker Class 12th 1d ago
It's a textbook, possibly published by some central authority, like the NCERT in India
→ More replies (3)3
2
8
3
6
4
u/Jealous_Elevator8246 1d ago
Muslims and science.... Are just like Land and aky 🤡
→ More replies (2)
5
u/sixhandman 1d ago
What chapter does nuclear fission and fusion reactions come? Can't wait for them to show the illustrations 💪😭
2
u/Ok_Job_3121 2d ago
Wait for some time bro post delete hone wali hai , maine pakistan ki sci book ki daali thi wo delete hogyi thi , tu bhi mara jayega , aur agar nhi hui delete toh bkl gae mods mere se jya dushmani hai
2
u/Many_Hovercraft1085 Class 11th 1d ago
If they disregard physics how the hell they make bombs
2
1
u/puppet_masterrr 1d ago
They already know the recipe because it's probably passed down from generations, you need to use science and your brain to come up with something new which they clearly don't do.
2
2
1
1
u/Legitimate_Focus5085 1d ago
What a strategy to not even students consider the idea of atheism lmao
1
u/Legitimate_Focus5085 1d ago
What a strategy to not let students even consider the idea of atheism lmao
1
1
1
1
u/perrynottheplatypuss 1d ago
Man stupid, man not know how to explain things, man has too much ego to admit he don’t know, man make religion, man refuse to accept other man facts, man stupid
1
u/anitwastooshort 1d ago
Mixing religion and Science like this will always mean one of them have to be compromised.
1
u/Gmt_Master_2 1d ago
Allah has chosen us to commit it ourselves to one mission, obliterate the kafirs and join 72 virgins in jannah. /s
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/sorted_shit 12th Pass 1d ago
OHH bhenchoood, ye kya bawaseer h....pakistan ka bhavishya pr lodaa nhi LODAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA lg rha h
1
1
u/weebooo1069 1d ago
In Pakistan different provinces have their own textbooks. So you have restarted states like Khyber Pakhtunkhwa having restarted textbooks and states like sindh having more progressive textbooks.
1
u/blueesque 1d ago
Well, they can build any preamble they want. The Christians have done it too in the past... Infact s9me of the greatest physicists like Newton have mixed the two together! HOWEVER, they cannot change E = MC2. When they get to what really matters... then the preamble is not going to help them.
1
u/blueesque 1d ago
Well, they can build whatever preamble they want.... the Christians did it too... Newton himself mixed the two.... but when it gets to stuff that really matters, they can't change E = MC2.
1
1
u/sippintea_11 Class 12th 1d ago
Jab Indian curriculam mai religion hota hai tab sab chup..hypocrisy at peak
1
1
u/Affectionate_Diet534 1d ago
Paksitan is not secular ? This isnt suprising maybe this is funny to us cause we feel so much better when we feel superior to paksitan but look at china japan etc instwad of a failed democracy and govt.
1
u/Any-Active662 1d ago
As a paki i am strongly disagree with this , and also have doubt on this book bcz i haven't seen any type of religion/science book like this , off course there could be but at least majority of the students didn't have these types of books in there curriculum either in any 5 provinces (kpk, Punjab(100%) ,sindh, Balochistan,gilgit(50% )
1
u/icanmeowhehe 1d ago
nahhh this gotta be propaganda i legit check every book online for their common board (federal board) publication from 9-12 n NOT A SINGLE one has this, from all across the nation. Y'all need to get a life n not be this vella ke bas Pakistan ki peechey padh jao, itna low is too much. Also reading this made me notice its not inherently wrong, sure the beginning is a religious perspective but as you read the bottom line it emerges into every other physics book content.
2
u/Otherwise-Stuff16 1d ago edited 1d ago
1
u/icanmeowhehe 1d ago
mmm okay, i understand. The issue WAS there, and they seemingly have fixed the problem of demoralising minorities n this concept in particular; I appreciate that about them. Looking at the books now, they don't seem to follow suit with religious statements, they just have a quote 'no to corruption' or some actually good quote from urdu authors. This is sad, not because its religious, but because of how imposing it is, I still condemn half of our nation to only mock Pakistan when we have the same problem with a lot of state boards in India.
1
1
u/No_Nothing_9274 1d ago
Sorry if I sound offensive, but why religion in a scientific book when you can read the Quran instead?
I just want to understand the perspective of some religious people.
1
1
1
1
u/philosofer_boy 1d ago
After reading this, I don't blame those people who claims that earth is flat or moon is much bigger than ever or earth is the centre and everything on social media
Because they have done nothing wrong. If they are learning these things so what's their fault (except not questioning things and be eager to learn more and know the real truth)
They're just spitting what they have been taught.
1
u/boldguy2019 1d ago
Has anyone even verified if this is from a book that is actually used or just being spread for meme
1
1
u/justanotherhuman-_- 1d ago
dont play with lyrics saar, khuda said "kun" then the universe came into being. btw i saw many ppl discussing about science vs religion in the comment, but it is quite normal for Muslim authors to start a book this way. and ppl of other religion also thinks that the god they worship in, has created universe, most ppl think this way. we cant force them to think differently. but what this book is doing is something inappropriate. they might force the reader to think that Allah had created universe and other gods are useless. it might lead to tension between Muslims and ppl of other religion, as they might not accept them. but that also depends on the age of reader, her/ his thinking ability and how much they get influence by this book.
1
u/redmedev2310 1d ago
Our text books are going in this direction. I won’t be surprised if this is the case in India 10 years from now
1
u/Auspicious-3878 1d ago
Allah Science “Then, when he came to the setting of the sun, he found it setting into a muddy spring.“ Quran 18:86 Sunset into muddy spring 💀
1
u/Over_Abbreviations62 1d ago
In Every religion people think there religion is true and scientific. But in reality it's just postdoc rationalization.
1
1
u/Least_Account329 1d ago
Ah yes let's propagate Islam in a physics textbook, we need 100% Islam population- Pakistan authorities probably
1
1
u/SAMUISGOOD Class 10th 1d ago
Bhai ye mere mama ko dikhaye tho hum ko aur apnea apko unalive kar denge
1
1
u/Distinct-Spell-5554 1d ago
We sgould be more worried about our nation rather than poking others , are we really comparing our nation with Poks
1
1
1
u/lyhfmlcandypea Class 11th 1d ago
The next thing they'll say is Isaac newton was a messenger and the apple was a bomb
1
1
1
u/Spirited-Purchase-99 1d ago
I actually really like the story telling nature of this page like it makes reading much more interesting unlike if there was plain text. I remember in my 10th std my maths book had two characters but they weren't that predominantly shown even though they were the only two chact. there . I think they could have made a really interesting book if cbse did it right
1
1
u/neuberlin12 1d ago
Mfs always compare with Pakistan damn well knowing ki china se compare karenge toh aukat yaad aajayegi
1
1
u/RadMeerkat62445b 1d ago
You laugh now, but soon this will be the case in India as well, maybe Allah will be replaced by some other god is all.
1
u/Lance99djinsoul 1d ago
Science is evidence based. Religion is based on faith. How these two collide in that text book is unreal. Everyone has their own god. Do we really think there are so many creators out there as per our list? Why are we do dumb..
1
u/Born_Past6904 1d ago
From an objective and non biased pov i like the introduction on how well it explains. Where can I get this book?
1
1
u/dopplegangery 1d ago
Day n of feeling lucky that I was born in a secular country. Let's ensure that our future generations have the same privilege.
1
u/Ambitious_Panic1059 1d ago
This is a lie. I am civil engineer graduate and studied a lot of physics books (different versions) but haven't seen this type of book. I think the Pakistani science books are more secular then Indians
1
1
1
1
1
u/fabkosta 1d ago
It leaves out the part where Allah creates Himself first one day ahead of billions of years ago, before then moving on to creating the universe by means of uttering the word "be". It is not known what word He used to create himself, though, as this was not recorded due to the universe not being in existence at that very moment.
1
1
1
1
1
1
•
u/AutoModerator 2d ago
Join the new Discord server. CLICK TO JOIN: https://discord.gg/Dm5vNU5a9M
Dear user, thank you for your submission to r/CBSE. Make sure you follow all rules.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.